Who is really an Idol? A look at our top 12.

[TaylorHicksRocks]

Originally Posted by Lancelot of Camelot

Taylor I rewatched Tuesdays show with my sick old mom today paying particular attention to David Cook and Jason Castro. After hearing these two again I see what you heard in them. Davids Rock N Roll version of hello was very comparable to Bryan Adams. It just didn't sink in for me on the first listen. The song that Jason sang was simply an awesome song and he did it very well. Each time he went into the Alleluia verse I got goosebumps. I still think that their voices can't compare with David A but judging just on this Tuesdays performance I can see why a person might prefer David C. and Jason. They have moved into the 2-3 slots for me among the males.

Oh Cool!! That is fantastic I don't ever watch them but I do listen always so it's more about originality and song choices that are incredible to me right now....It's more for my ears anyway not my eyes....That's the one thing I have always said is you listen with your ears..

[Lancelot of Camelot]

Originally Posted by TaylorHicksRocks

Oh Cool!! That is fantastic I don't ever watch them but I do listen always so it's more about originality and song choices that are incredible to me right now....It's more for my ears anyway not my eyes....That's the one thing I have always said is you listen with your ears..

You never watch AI you just turn it on and listen to it? Is that what you are saying? WOW.

[Feisty Kitty]

Originally Posted by Chopper7

SOS has way too much spare time. He wrote more in one comment than I've written in a year!

He actually has very little spare time, just a great brain and great typing skills! I wish my hand/ brain/ eye coordination was a great as his!