This is really only for those interested in the competition - it isn't ALL by any means (I know, because I'm missing some of my favourite comments I've come across before)
But here are the comments almost from day 1
and I ran out of steam - so will try and add to them later.
--------------------
Bits dredged from the past Positive stuff - any ....... will be in order to keep the niceties...
Wow - back right near the beginning...
Hmm. I thought that the round 3 verdict was the best out of all of them. The ppl with talent actually got in!! Shannon has the best voice, and Guy's voice, personality, and the way he can change songs to make it his own is great! Rebekah was also really really good, and i hope she is the wildcard entry. In all the other rounds, ONLY Peter (pig farmer) has talent.
Apart from Guy, I'm right behind this girl. (Paulini) Talk about VOICE. It all comes down to the vocals right. Guy and Paulini have got their stuff packed down!! These two better get somewhere.... FAR
. Post the 70s show. (Holden loves him and wants him voted thru, even tho he didn't think he did his best performance)
Guy: I love Guy! He's awesome. The judges didn't like his performance tonight, but personally, I really enjoyed it. He's got an awesome voice and he's a good performer - he looks like he really enjoys himself on-stage. I'm definitely going to be rooting for this guy all the way through the competition; he kicks ass.
Post You're the Voice. (In a way a dangerous choice, because it is one of THE Australian anthems and John Farnham is THE VOICE. However, its one of the US fans faves).
GUY: Surprising Farnham choice, but nothing really wrong with the performance except for the fact that it was a little too Hillsong. Beaming from ear to ear throughout, he really seemed to enjoy himself and had terrific rapport with the audience. No worries here, two good weeks in a row for Guy. 8/10
When doves Cry - when Guy started to pull in huge fans... Guy - words can not describe how good he was..... he has such a beautiful voice that it literally gives me goose pimple (i love the vocal acrobatics)... he is just as good as Paulini and has a great chance of winning it
Oct 12 2003 GUY: Would love to see him win this competition. Talented, original, funky, genuine, and in Marcia's voice, heaven-sent voice. Really enjoyed his performance tonight. He funked it up to the max - almost had a bit of an accident with the mike at the end there, but besides that, practically faultless. (LOL - obviously post When Doves Cry)
From a non committal 'critic' Guy improved tonight, a bit awkward, but starting to show some attitude (if a bit deliberately). But he needs more of that killer instinct to win. Has potential to grow though, like Paulini.
Discussion was getting a little 'taut' at this point about others still in the comp. (Def. not one of Pinkline's favourites) I think I need gods help sometimes! Danzig, couldn't agree more.. It is just a hard thing to find! I just like to see what the real people, who care enough about these Idols, to post comments about them in places like this really think.. It is not an idustry about talent as much as it should be.. This is why we are subjected to very little new "real" talent any more. Guy is truly a shining light in terms of vocal skills in a very large niche that people love or hate.. His voice and image will by no means apeal to all.. The shame is that his clear cut stand alone talent will not get him through.. ........
post immediately following the above: Totally agree with everything you say about Guy "In the biz", I really do hope Australia won't let this very rare talent pass by.
Concerned poster - VOTE FOR THE VOICE As I've stated before Guy seems to be the only one who has the whole package as he definitely has the voice.
Following the Unplugged show (When I Get You Alone) Guy - Absolutley awesome performance, as always. He worked the crowd, got into it. Made the song sound real good. He also looks killa in a pair of jeans. He should win Australian Idol by far!
also from WIGYA Guy – By far this is his best performance, unbelievably awesome. He is the complete package. He not only has the look, image (Go Tha Fro) and the attitude but he can really work the crowd fantastically. As I’ve said b4, and will continue to say, Guy should definitely win Australian Idol.
Post Wigya (poster sez its a Beck song - but its actually from Robin Thicke) Guy- A Beck song. Superb performance. He's the only one who looked like he was really enjoying himself onstage tonight. Questions- a little awestruck by the audience... and easily distracted
Post Wigya Guy - thats tops mate! no other idol could've sung that song. --------------
------ guy - the best performance of the night - vocally was fantastic, moved around the stage - and you could tell he was thoroughly enjoying himself ! -----------
---------- This poster a bit of a 'thinker'
Guy's song choice really made use of the string section. And it was an interesting song, not an obvious, boring, pop standard. He is interesting, but he needs to come out of his shell more.
Ganesha - who loves music fanatically
Nicely put, I hope there are enough like you out there, and i dont just mean for this shows validity! I personally want Guy to win because of those reasons you mentioned however sometimes i think the real talents are better off not winning if you know what i mean.
SERIOUSLY WHO THINKS GUY IS TOPS! HE IS IN A LEAGUE OF HIS OWN. AFTER WATCHING HIM OVER THE PAST WEEK INCLUDING WHEN DOVES CRY --------------
------ )From Ganesha again) He is the best no doubt, world class is just the start. --------------
-------- I have to agree with you guys. Guy does an amazing job every week. He picks good songs, makes them his own. Looks funky. Dances well. He's the complete package. He should definately win Australian Idol by far. --------------
-----------
---------- guy will nail this sundays rnb soul! there's no way he'll be voted out!!!! i really like to see him do a moonwalk...that will put the nail in the coffin. I wish i had heaps of cash....i'll sign him up right away...or i can get my friend who works @ virgin mobile to get Richard Branson to sign him up.
(and for fun, Ganesha's reply to Pinkline)
Pinkline i think you should calm that ego down a tad, insulting the one person who clearly stands out above the rest kind of makes you look like a ****. I am a musician myself, my parents were musicians, my mother had an extrodinary voice and i know what is special, and Guy has blown my mind with his incredible subtelty and impressive interpretations. Theres a post talking about you being credible....how old are you? What exactly gives you credibility? --------------
Guy does rock and i really do hope he does win! --------------
---- I Totally agree! Guy is so the best! If he wins I will buy every one of his CD's from beginning to end! His voice is unique but soooo nice and hes got the look and all! I've never seen him do bad at a concert so far... and I dont think he ever will! ;D We Love you Guy!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! --------------
--------------
-
I love reading these comments Lyn. I was hooked on Guy but hadn't discovered the internet and forums at this stage so it's good to read what people were saying back then.sweetpea2well, one day the proboards will disappear and its nice to have these somewhere else too. I'll go back 'em up sometime and paste them here, at home. Wow - Ganesha called him a top one in the world, or similar... and that was then. HUGE praise indeed I hope he's gone to see him at Parramatta or whatever - every time we see Guy he's advanced another 2 or 3 steps higher than he was before
Bits Dredged - part 2
Post RnB (Hidden Agenda and Hello - both Guy arrangements, particularly the last)
GUY: 'Hidden Agenda' was flawless - sounded an awful lot like Craig David though so didn't completely make it his own, but either way, enjoyable. 'Hello' was good - his voice was awesome as per usual, but undecided about the arrangement. Hmmm. ----------------
GUY: Very professional and musical. The most grounded performer. Solid, but not as dazzling as other times. Can imagine him in the Final 2- maybe against Millsy! (*coff*) -----------------
GUY - His first song 'Hidden Agenda' was awesome, but his real accomplishment I think was 'Hello'. I love the original and I feel his version was excellent. It really shows how into his music he is. His voice (as always) was absolutely brilliant. -----------------
Guy - LOVED his two performances. His voice was fantastic and he had such wonderful stage presence. This guy is a STAR. Levi was my favorite idol contestant but now Guy is up there as well as one of my favorites. GO GUY! (I'm going to go buy the Craig David cd now after hearing Guy's wonderful rendition of 'Hidden Agenda'

) -----------------
speaking of top 2, Guy is definitely there. i believe he was the best performer of the night. he has an amazing voice and he performed both of his songs fantastically. -----------------
Guy....again, he is a champion! Was a bit worried about Hidden Agenda, but as the judges say "he pulled it off"...and Hello! What a brilliant performance. -----------------
Guy is the only real talent and real artist in this competition. He looks funky and has no attitude (like the rest). He should win! Go Guy!!!! -----------------
Guy was fab fab fab i loved the songs he did even tho it is not my type of music, i tink he deserves to win. -----------------