The Judges

[eureka735]

I love this show but truthfully it is absolutely getting absurd. Simon is honest in his critiques and does try to give constructive criticism. Paula is absolutely useless. She says nothing that is sensible...only how beautiful they look. And Randy who I always liked before has become way too wishy washy. He used to offer good advice but is almost as bad as Paula now. "It was just alright for me dawg". Same thing every single time....I read somewhere that Simon may cancel the show if America keeps Sanjaya in because he is cute. He is ridiculaous and at best sounds like he should be in a high school musical. They should change the name of the show and the judges should vote... not America because America treats this show as a popularity contest not one of talent!

[Mister_J]

Originally Posted by eureka735

I love this show but truthfully it is absolutely getting absurd. Simon is honest in his critiques and does try to give constructive criticism. Paula is absolutely useless. She says nothing that is sensible...only how beautiful they look. And Randy who I always liked before has become way too wishy washy. He used to offer good advice but is almost as bad as Paula now. "It was just alright for me dawg". Same thing every single time....I read somewhere that Simon may cancel the show if America keeps Sanjaya in because he is cute. He is ridiculaous and at best sounds like he should be in a high school musical. They should change the name of the show and the judges should vote... not America because America treats this show as a popularity contest not one of talent!

America is mostly about the image anyway. I've seen some pros that i don't think are that good.

[jgrv]

I'm in total agreement with you, MisterJ.

[kelly]

Originally Posted by Mister_J

America is mostly about the image anyway. I've seen some pros that i don't think are that good.

Right on MJ !

[Daisy Brown]

Have been searching for my comments from early am. titled frustrated. trying to find them so I could print and save them for SanJays scrap book when he becomes famous will mail them to him. I want to be a part of his survival.

One comment "Cheers to Poppy eyed Tom the Canadian on CW5. He was among first to bash SanJaya. This am he made the admirable comment that and I quote
"Referring to the Massacre, Tom said or realized the culprit might have been
a rejected Kid in the school which hit the wrong stress nerve and put him over the edge. When he made this comment he referred to kids being rejected on Americn Idol. I am referring to the abuse and ridicule aimed at
Sanjaya. Sometimes you do not kno what is behing a wide white smile. my point is keep your mouth shut and your nasty comments to yourself. Take a look at your self. Tanks