March 9 and 10

[X1TX]

Siobhan has a great voice. She and Paige are better vocalists than Crystal. But Crystal is the better artist.

[Lancelot of Camelot]

Originally Posted by X1TX

Siobhan has a great voice. She and Paige are better vocalists than Crystal. But Crystal is the better artist.

IMO Paige not better vocalist than Crystal. Not even on par with Crystal at all.

[Lancelot of Camelot]

Guys all ok so far but no stand outs and I don't think there will be any standouts. They just don't have the talent.

[Lancelot of Camelot]

I can actually see Casey making it as a Country singer. He fits for that genre.

[Lancelot of Camelot]

I liked all of Aaron, Toddrick and Michael. Michael was definitely the best vocal of the night and he of course has the presence. Agree that he is should now be the favorite of the men.

[Chopper7]

I have to admit that each week I keep thinking that one or two of the guys is going to make an impression. I doubt I can keep that up. Kara pretty much summed up the insanity by proclaiming that Alex Lambert's only barrier to WINNING is himself. Now, first that's just a silly thing to say, and it's really silly to say it of a guy who cannot sing on tune, has zero stage presence, and owns a sappy, weak, reedy voice. Yep, he's a shoo-in to win it all. I can see the Kris fans jumping up and down for this weak sister. Also if all these guys are so adorable for Ellen, why is she gay?

[Chopper7]

OK, Kara finally did it. She was so outrageous, she made me puke! I wrote my last note before I heard Todrick and Michael. Todrick, little sleaze that he is, hammed it up and may have bought himself another week. Michael delivered an imaginative, semi-inspired performance, but gang, it wasn't that good. To listen to the judges, he laid a new foundation for greatness. What a fraud! The only one I liked was Casey because he didn't try to do anything except to hang onto his spot in the final 12. Sing a simple little song with a range of about five notes and don't budge from your chair. Very impressive. Hey, who goes home? He, who cares?

[Lancelot of Camelot]

Originally Posted by Chopper7

OK, Kara finally did it. She was so outrageous, she made me puke! I wrote my last note before I heard Todrick and Michael. Todrick, little sleaze that he is, hammed it up and may have bought himself another week. Michael delivered an imaginative, semi-inspired performance, but gang, it wasn't that good. To listen to the judges, he laid a new foundation for greatness. What a fraud! The only one I liked was Casey because he didn't try to do anything except to hang onto his spot in the final 12. Sing a simple little song with a range of about five notes and don't budge from your chair. Very impressive. Hey, who goes home? He, who cares?

I rewatched the last two weeks shows with my mom today. I think Michael is very good. I didn't notice it at first but he is easily the best voice of the guys. That last performance was flawless and he also has great stage presence. He is not as good as Crystal or Siobhan but he is probably the third best of the singers.

[Teddy G]

Originally Posted by Chopper7

I have to admit that each week I keep thinking that one or two of the guys is going to make an impression. I doubt I can keep that up. Kara pretty much summed up the insanity by proclaiming that Alex Lambert's only barrier to WINNING is himself. Now, first that's just a silly thing to say, and it's really silly to say it of a guy who cannot sing on tune, has zero stage presence, and owns a sappy, weak, reedy voice. Yep, he's a shoo-in to win it all. I can see the Kris fans jumping up and down for this weak sister. Also if all these guys are so adorable for Ellen, why is she gay?

I really don't understand why the judges are so nuts about Alex.

He's horrible. He's off-key most of the time, and his voice is real weak.

[TaylorHicksRocks]

I don't care for Andrew but I do like Tim...

I adore Siobhan, Didi doesn't impress that much, Crystal knocked it out of the park!!!