Sabrina and Sundance gone?

[kelly]

I am sorely disappointed that Sabrina left! She was very talented in her melody and harmony vocals. She had the widest range of vocals I think! Haley is good but Sabrina is better. Sanjaya should have definitely gone. He's way bad. Hula? What "guy" says he can hula?

Sundance should have stayed because he has a unique voice and has a good range as well. His vocals got better toward the end.

I'm not so sure America needs to vote anymore. The judges just need to decide from now on.

[idolchat.tv]

Originally Posted by kelly

I am sorely disappointed that Sabrina left! She was very talented in her melody and harmony vocals. She had the widest range of vocals I think! Haley is good but Sabrina is better. Sanjaya should have definitely gone. He's way bad. Hula? What "guy" says he can hula?

Sundance should have stayed because he has a unique voice and has a good range as well. His vocals got better toward the end.

I'm not so sure America needs to vote anymore. The judges just need to decide from now on.

Yeah you're right. Whats the point of them critquing anyone if they can't judge. Viewers only vote according to all the wrong reasons obviously. Im so pissed that Sabrina got voted off I could SCREEEEEAM...

ARRRRRRRRRRRRRGH

[Dea]

I will scream along with you.......In the begining I wanted her to win......

[idolchat.tv]

Originally Posted by Dea

I will scream along with you.......In the begining I wanted her to win......

I think I actually heard you.... relax

[gregorysanfran]

O.K. Kelly....

I agree with you Sanjaya SHOULD NOT have stayed.
His singing is fair... and definitelty not idol material.

BUT... you are insulting when you make fun of his "hula"
i.e. "what kind of guy would hula".... many.... straight and
gay.....

so please don't mix singing review with inappropriate
name calling based on gender stud-ness vs. effeminite...

just stick to the fact that he shouldn't have won...
don't make a mockery of other lifestyles just because
Sanjaya can't sing... O.K.

gregory

[rocca978]

This is just terrible!!! How did Sanjaya and Haley get through????

I'm so sad for Sabrina...all the girls up there, with the exception of Antonella and Haley were really good and deserved to be in the top 12. If America cannot be fair and vote for the good singers, then I think the voting should be done by the judges....but then again, it wouldn't be called American Idol!!

Sanjaya is a sweet boy, but he cannot sing like the others can...he should have been gone two or three weeks ago!!! Week after week he's proven that he can't bring it. He's going to be like John Stevens from a few years ago (red head), that's going to be around for a while and knock out deserving people. He's getting the Indian population vote...obviously they want an indian to win, rather than a good singer!!

Haley has got an okay voice....but nowhere in the same league as the other girls. I hope she gets voted out next week. I'm just sooooo happy Antonella got the boot!!! She was horrible!!!

I feel bad for Sundance and Jared....but I wasn't surprised that either of them got the boot...I think one of them should have stayed over Sunjaya though!!

[Finalfantasy]

This is what I noticed. Antonella and Jared were voted off first BUT they placed Haley with Sabrina AND Sunjaya with Sundance.

Sundance and Sabrina voters will start swinging their votes making sure BOTH of them are booted out.

[bjabbott27]

Originally Posted by rocca978

This is just terrible!!! How did Sanjaya and Haley get through????

I'm so sad for Sabrina...all the girls up there, with the exception of Antonella and Haley were really good and deserved to be in the top 12. If America cannot be fair and vote for the good singers, then I think the voting should be done by the judges....but then again, it wouldn't be called American Idol!!

Sanjaya is a sweet boy, but he cannot sing like the others can...he should have been gone two or three weeks ago!!! Week after week he's proven that he can't bring it. He's going to be like John Stevens from a few years ago (red head), that's going to be around for a while and knock out deserving people. He's getting the Indian population vote...obviously they want an indian to win, rather than a good singer!!

Haley has got an okay voice....but nowhere in the same league as the other girls. I hope she gets voted out next week. I'm just sooooo happy Antonella got the boot!!! She was horrible!!!

I feel bad for Sundance and Jared....but I wasn't surprised that either of them got the boot...I think one of them should have stayed over Sunjaya though!!

I was very surprised that Sundance was voted out! He did not have a great performance Tuesday, but overall he has proven that he has one of the best male voices. Sunjaya is an indian Michael Jackson wannabe. He should never have even been in the competition, much less how far he has gotten. Maybe the judged should determine who stays in. After all, they are much better qualified!

[angelinhiseyes1969]

Was America watching the same show i was this week...What's up send Sabrina and Sundance packing and keep Haley and Sanjaya????? I have to agree with Simon there must have been a lot of tv volumes turned down...I do not understand this at all....Also i think that we should be keeping our money in America, not Africa...When are these countries going to be able to take care of there own? Come on , we have people sleeping under bridges, for god sake.... starr

[idolchat.tv]

Originally Posted by angelinhiseyes1969

Was America watching the same show i was this week...What's up send Sabrina and Sundance packing and keep Haley and Sanjaya????? I have to agree with Simon there must have been a lot of tv volumes turned down...I do not understand this at all....Also i think that we should be keeping our money in America, not Africa...When are these countries going to be able to take care of there own? Come on , we have people sleeping under bridges, for god sake.... starr

I think this week there were a number of votes from deaf people. That would be the only explanation of what we saw (heard) last night. American Idol viewers just took 2 steps back.