Theme for next week

[Chopper7]

I have to admit that I agree with Lance that Siobhan has the best voice in the competition, also the best training. She also has a range that's about an octave larger than most of the others. What are these flaws that need exposing?

Originally Posted by Teddy G

Yeah, that pretty much sums up my feelings. I think she's trying to make her performances a little more over the top, to make up for her shortcomings as a singer. Whereas, if she would just sing a song, without all the gimmicks, like Crystal does, her flaws would be exposed.

Another thing is if it were any other season, I don't think she would stand out as much. But, the fact that the talent pool is so weak, makes her a big fish in a small pond.

[Teddy G]

Originally Posted by Chopper7

What are these flaws that need exposing?

Well, to me, she sounded a little flat a few times. Especially at the beginning of 'Superstition' and most of 'House Of The Rising Sun', and 'Paint It Black'. Then she goes into shreik-mode, which seems to save her.

I don't really enjoy listening to Siobhan sing slow songs, or slow parts of songs. It just doesn't sound pleasing to me. It always seems a little flat and mediocre. If I heard her sing these songs on the radio, I would probably turn the station, right away. Whereas, I could probably listen to Crystal sing anything, and enjoy it.

On the other hand, I really enjoyed her performance of 'Think'. That was probably my favorite performance of her's.