March 9 and 10

[Lancelot of Camelot]

Wow Lilly gone. This really sucks. How Lacey, Paige and Didi lasted longer is shocking.

[Teddy G]

I'm disappointed that Lilly is gone, even though her last performance was totally wacked.

It should've been Paige or Lacey.

[Chopper7]

Let's see. Todrick was guilty of being a sleazy show-off, Alex of singing like a whiny dog, Lilly of torturing a great song, and Katelyn of being too attractive. Lilly also probably failed because she doesn't have the bubble-gummer cell-phone hysteria attraction responsible for Paige, Lacey, and a flock of ordinary guys. I actually was glad Katie made it through because she at least could improve, no reason to think she will however. The babies will persist in voting for her and the other teener, Aaron who showed this week just how bad a singer he really is. Both can continue to stink and hang around. Kudos to Paige and Tim. VFTW is really flexing its muscle so far. Fortunately, I forgot to watch the teary-eyed results show this week.

[Chopper7]

Didi has actually been pretty good, and she's really pretty. The girls will knock her out for looks soon just as they did Katelyn. Didi is a much better singer than anyone left in the show except Crystal and Siobhan.

Originally Posted by Lancelot of Camelot

Wow Lilly gone. This really sucks. How Lacey, Paige and Didi lasted longer is shocking.

[Teddy G]

Originally Posted by Chopper7

Fortunately, I forgot to watch the teary-eyed results show this week.

Well, you would've seen Katie cry like a baby.

Dry up, kid. You're here for another week.

[Lancelot of Camelot]

Originally Posted by Chopper7

Didi has actually been pretty good, and she's really pretty. The girls will knock her out for looks soon just as they did Katelyn. Didi is a much better singer than anyone left in the show except Crystal and Siobhan.

Katie and Mike easily better singers than Didi IMO.

[X1TX]

What did Lillly in was her oddball song this week. I did kind of like her quirky oddness. As far as a voice, she was good, but not one of the best. I do think she had a lot more growth potential. She's more of an odd version of Crystal. I think she could have a niche audience. Todrick has a decent voice, but not great. If he didn't leave this week, it would be in the next week or two. Katelyn has a good voice, but didn't do anything to stand out. And her last performance was like a lounge act more than a star in the making performance.

And is it me, or does it seem like the judges want to see a finale' with Mike and Crystal?

[Jeremiah]

Todrick really annoyed me; I'm kind of glad he's gone. He could maybe get picked up to be in a Broadway show, but American Idol was the wrong kind of competition for him.