Who Should Have Gone Home Instead Of Ace!!!!

[cinnamocha]

Ace Was One Of The Reasons We Watch American Idol!
He Not Only Has An Amazing Voice, He Is Versitile, And Beautiful!!!!


Paris Should Have Gone Home This Week! She Is So Boring!!!

[Fan-tastic]

I didn't see the Wednesday show, so had to go online to find out who was out. I was surprised it was Ace, for the following reasons.
Granted, he did not do a great job on Tuesday night, BUT, based on what the show is supposed to be about, he should still be a contestant.
I don't know if Paris is boring, exactly, I think she just lacks experience. She has a remarkable voice, and if she can keep her head on straight, she'll be a successful performer, but she's just not my idea of an American Idol. But using that thread, neither was Ruebin Studdard (sp?).

I think the performer should have the whole package, the voice - first and foremost, then stage presence, the ability to move and not look comical and looks. That's why I think Elliot will make a good Broadway star - he's got the voice and unless you're in the first 6 rows, you won't be able to see his face clearly.

McPhee and Chris have the whole package, in my humble opinion. I just wish Ace the best. He was awfully nice to look at, even if he wouldn't look my way. I hope he finds success.

[McFeverish.....]

Such an easy question Cinnamocha.

Ace surely wasn't the WORST on tuesday.

That was Kellie, and that pickle needed to be hacked!

[buddyrj]

It is a matter of opinion...
I believe that Paris is much much better singer and more versatile than Ace, and she is also the reason why a lot of people watch AI (as Ace was for you). She is boring for you, exciting for me... I love to hear her voice, she is only 17 and has a powerful voice. I do not know if she will win, probably not, but it does not matter, with her voice she will build a great future in music.

But aswering your question, I think that Kellie is the worst...

My favorite is Chris, but for me it will be good to see him or any other of the real talented singers in this competition (Chris, Paris, Taylor, Elliot and Kat) at the finals... It is a pity that Mandisa is not participating anymore... she is great!

[FalseIdol]

Ace surely wasn't the WORST on tuesday.



Quit calling him Shirley.

[cinnamocha]

Quit calling him Shirley.

LOL!!!:boldred:

[LikesMusic]

PICKLES was terrible! She has got to go!

[frank]

Ryan F"ing Seacrest

[maggiespk]

Kellie should be booted

[RushDog]

Kellie should stay. She means the world to me.

[graciespeaks]

In a way I am glad Ace went last week, I am tired of defending him.
I still like him and if he puts out a CD I will buy it.
Although, the amount of attention Ace gets on these threads seem to have gotten worse instead of better, and this is not the place for Ace fans.

[FalseIdol]

In a way I am glad Ace went last week, I am tired of defending him.
I still like him and if he puts out a CD I will buy it.


That's only because you feel silly when people see you still buying Backstreet Boys CD's.

Ace's CD should be called "Backdoor Boys".

[graciespeaks]

I bought those CD's for you!!
Ace's CD should be called something like...Love Songs to Make Women Smile..
or...I Can Make You Happy!