We don't pick the Idol!

[MusicLover]

We can all see who's AI has been promoting so far, who's been given all the praise, all the air time, all the Interviews. AI won't let someone win that they know won't sell records and make them tons of $dough$, that's just pure common sense. And, as crappy as that sounds, it's show business, it's Hollywood. :(

[frank]

We can all see who's AI has been promoting so far, who's been given all the praise, all the air time, all the Interviews. AI won't let someone win that they know won't sell records and make them tons of $dough$, that's just pure common sense. And, as crappy as that sounds, it's show business, it's Hollywood. :(
Really? This all sounds oddly familiar. I seem to remember someone here posting the exact same thought. Hmmmmm, let's see, who was it? Oh yeah.....MEEEEEEEEEEE!!!!!
I'm assuming that you are inferring that PickleHead is the one. At Least WWW.VoteForTheWorst.COM most certainly agrees, and loves you very much. As I do .........

[graciespeaks]

America chooses the AI guys, bring yourselves back to reality!!
All of the contestants are very talented, just because everyone doesnt like your favorite doesnt mean they are wrong.
I have NOT seen AI give any extra time to any one contestant. They are, though, clearly giving each a moment to clear up a question about themselves, if they want to. Which I think is fine!
Remember, it is a talent competition but the talent is in the eye of the beholder!!!

[Skate]

Don't be too quick to believe everything you are told.

I'd like to think it's as simple & straightforward as viewers' votes determining who stays & who goes but I'm afraid it isn't.

Sure, the votes may count for something but who knows? The producers may be playing a game.

The "reality" in reality television is really a lot of programming.

[cloie4me]

If I believed that we didnt pick the AI winner, then I wouldn't watch and I certainly wouldnt vote. Lets try out the theory. NOBODY vote next week and lets see what happens.

(gracie, me and you will still vote, only their favorites will go home. hehe)

[tinsong]

If I believed that we didnt pick the AI winner, then I wouldn't watch and I certainly wouldnt vote. Lets try out the theory. NOBODY vote next week and lets see what happens.

(gracie, me and you will still vote, only their favorites will go home. hehe)
Okay - you scared me there for a minute - about not voting. I'm with y'all - I'm voting for Taylor! It wouldn't matter to me if everybody else went home. You vote, of course for the one you want and (like you said) everybody else's favorite just might go. Good idea!
lol

[frank]

America chooses the AI guys, bring yourselves back to reality!!
All of the contestants are very talented, just because everyone doesn't like your favorite doesn't mean they are wrong.
I have NOT seen AI give any extra time to any one contestant. They are, though, clearly giving each a moment to clear up a question about themselves, if they want to. Which I think is fine!
Remember, it is a talent competition but the talent is in the eye of the beholder!!!
It's nice to see that some of the A.I. producers are not afraid to come onto this message board. But the show is still not honest.

[cloie4me]

Okay - you scared me there for a minute - about not voting. I'm with y'all - I'm voting for Taylor! It wouldn't matter to me if everybody else went home. You vote, of course for the one you want and (like you said) everybody else's favorite just might go. Good idea!
lol

I love you tinsong! and Taylor will always get my vote.

[RushDog]

We can all see who's AI has been promoting so far, who's been given all the praise, all the air time, all the Interviews. AI won't let someone win that they know won't sell records and make them tons of $dough$, that's just pure common sense. And, as crappy as that sounds, it's show business, it's Hollywood. :(


The only comment that I have to that one is that Reuben hasn't exactly made the impact that you might expect an AI winner to make. He's kinda fallen by the wayside.

[graciespeaks]

It's nice to see that some of the A.I. producers are not afraid to come onto this message board. But the show is still not honest.
Frank, who do you think has not gotten extra airtime?

[graciespeaks]

And in reality most of AI money comes from the show itself, not from the winner!!!

[litl1kj]

I am new to this site and was reading some of the comments. I think Kellie does get more air time because she makes good TV with her "dumb Blonde" comments. If she says some thing off the wall It keeps things entertaining. Look at the whole Jessica Simpson chicken or tuna comment. It was plastered all over TV and her reality show ratings went up just because people wanted to see what she would say next. I personally hope Kellie does'nt win idol not because she can't sing but because she is so innocent and naive that I think the music industry would be too stressful for her. I mean it is really a cut throat industry and I don't think she has the "balls" to handle some of the things she will be subjected to. That's just my opinion. :flamethro