Elliott a great singer? HAAA

[Boombatty]

I know I am gonna tick a million or so people off , but ohhh well! I just can not see how Elliott can be heralded as a great singer......he totally trashed the garth song and he sings every song the exact same way, and has absolutely no feeling or connection to the song. I will not as far as saying he can't sing at all, but he is far far from being a great singer or even one of the top 6 on AI this year.

[bigd13]

Who do you think is the best singer, Katharine, hell no. I guess you didn't see Elliot perform in his audition and when he went to Hollywood. He sung better than every guy there. I am really tired of people dissing the ones who can actually perform a song and actually get the ones at home into it and actually have some feeling when they sing. Elliot is the shit and I rather see him there than Katharine who brings nothing to a song when she sings and you probably think Katharine is all that, but she's not. Katharine is an alright singer, but as far as star power, she has none.

[RushDog]

I usually fast forward halfway through when Elliot sings. He's a good singer, he's just so boring. Him and Ace, man those guys put me to sleep.

[Boombatty]

Actually I thing Chris has been the most consistent thus far, but may run into trouble with future themes......overall I think this is a very week bunch on the show this year......well, weak being in the choice of songs......last week was horrible and this week wasn't much better across the board


Boring is perfect to describe Elliott.....if he ever get a record deal i might buy it as a sleep aid!

[cindyhoustontexas]

Elliott can sing but he has no star power...no "it" factor. He's just seems a little shy and unsure of himself and doesn't have a lot of personality. And he HAS to get those teeth fixed. I don't think he will make it to the top three, but he'll probably have a decent career ahead of him if he overcomes those obstacles I mentioned.

[RushDog]

He might have a decent wedding singer career, that's about it.

[Skate]

Elliott sure as hell can sing but yeah, he is pretty boring. Great to listen to, boring to watch & he needs to grow a personality.

Otherwise, we won't be looking at a star.

[schnauzermom]

I may be 'dating' myself here, but do you remember Jim Breuer's "GOAT BOY" character on Saturday Night Live?? I swear that is what Elliott sounds and reminds me of!! When he sings I just expect him to go "baaa" on some notes.... I do not think he is the best singer by far in this competition. He has no charisma at all. And what is up with the hair....

Well...that is my two cents worth....



I know I am gonna tick a million or so people off , but ohhh well! I just can not see how Elliott can be heralded as a great singer......he totally trashed the garth song and he sings every song the exact same way, and has absolutely no feeling or connection to the song. I will not as far as saying he can't sing at all, but he is far far from being a great singer or even one of the top 6 on AI this year.

[va_girl2468]

I personally think he's one of the best in the competition.

[FalseIdol]

He might have a decent wedding singer career, that's about it.

At least wedding singers occassionaly move. Watch Elliott, it seems as though his shoes are bolted to the stage.

But he definitely has that crying thing down for weddings.

[RushDog]

He'd make a good folk singer. They don't move much and he's got the same look as those guys on "A Mighty Wind".

[FalseIdol]

He'd make a good folk singer. They don't move much and he's got the same look as those guys on "A Mighty Wind".

You mean as in, "someone broke wind"?

[RushDog]

You'd have to see the movie to know what I'm talking about.

[kevinsgurl123]

elliott's hot!!

[CarrieUnderwood04]

Elliot is a horrible singer I don't know how he got so far on idol Chris should have gotten farther than him

[CarrieUnderwood04]

Elliot is so boring when he sings I can't even think of a performance that I liked he didn't get my attention

[lizzyj]

Opinions vary.

[RushDog]

I see Mr. Verbally Challenged is back.

[TaylorHicksRocks]

Elliot is so boring when he sings I can't even think of a performance that I liked he didn't get my attention

I can think of several times when Elliott's perfrmance got my attention! The last time was when he was singing Savin' Me with Chris In Milwaukee.....I never knew That man could ROCK! Wow He can rock!!! He was awesome in concert and I am looking forward to his album!!!! Diversity is what I like in music........

[CarrieUnderwood04]

I hate elliot he sucks

[TaylorHicksRocks]

If you hate someone you need to love them first. How can you love/hate someone you don't know? I mean really how old are you anyway? Because you don't sound like an adult.