Taylor, Elliot, Paris, and Mandisa= BOTTOM 4

[innocentdreamer]

Taylor, Paris, Mandisa, and Elliot need to leave NOW!!
They cant sing at all and I dont know why America has kept them here instead of Ayla and Lisa! As far as I'm concerned Ace, Chris, and Kathrine are my top 3!!!! Ace should WIN!!

[ihearttaylor]

hmmm... that's weird... the didn't Simon already say that Elliot was the best contestant YET?


and we all know that paris will get a contract no matter how she does on here.


and you have to give some respect to mandisa... look how confident and amazing she is. and that voice kicks some serious butt, too.


and taylor will be in the top three, more than likely. the american populous doesn't always have to have someone who follows the norm for their American Idol. and taylor portrays that image VERY well.

this isn't Beauty and the Geek.

[innocentdreamer]

hmmm... that's weird... the didn't Simon already say that Elliot was the best contestant YET?


and we all know that paris will get a contract no matter how she does on here.


and you have to give some respect to mandisa... look how confident and amazing she is. and that voice kicks some serious butt, too.


and taylor will be in the top three, more than likely. the american populous doesn't always have to have someone who follows the norm for their American Idol. and taylor portrays that image VERY well.

this isn't Beauty and the Geek.

HAHAHAHAHAHAH NO WAY!

[Anonymous X]

ACE
KELLIE
ELLIOT

will be the bottom 3.

[cinnamocha]

Taylor, Paris, Mandisa, and Elliot need to leave NOW!!
They cant sing at all and I dont know why America has kept them here instead of Ayla and Lisa! As far as I'm concerned Ace, Chris, and Kathrine are my top 3!!!! Ace should WIN!!

WELL SAID THIS IS THE BEST POST ON THIS FORUM!!!!
ACE OR KATHERINE SHOULD WIN

[buddyrj]

Sorry but you simply must be kidding or you do not understand anything about music and sing... Mandisa has one of the best voices ever in AI competition, as well as Paris, who is amazing for her age... and Elliot is really a better singer than Ace. Ok, Ace is a very handsome guy with a good voice, and it is ok to want to see him as the next American Idol, but please you do not need to say foolish things like "They cant sing at all"... because they really can sing, a lot! I think that Chris is the one who deserve to win this edition, but it cannot make me deaf and blind to the talent of the other contestants.

[Anonymous X]

PARIS, TAYLOR and MANDISA let me down tonight (April 3).

Those 3 used to be my favorites! :confused:

[cinnamocha]

Sorry but you simply must be kidding or you do not understand anything about music and sing... Mandisa has one of the best voices ever in AI competition, as well as Paris, who is amazing for her age... and Elliot is really a better singer than Ace. Ok, Ace is a very handsome guy with a good voice, and it is ok to want to see him as the next American Idol, but please you do not need to say foolish things like "They cant sing at all"... because they really can sing, a lot! I think that Chris is the one who deserve to win this edition, but it cannot make me deaf and blind to the talent of the other contestants.

We are a musical Family! The majority of our family LOVE KATHERINE's Singing.
As well as ACE. The other contestants in our opinion are just ok.

[pddccc]

Paris was horrid tonight.
Taylor wasnt great either.
IHEARTTAYLOR.SIMON did not say Elliott was the best contestant yet. He said he had the best male voice. Simon has said several times though that Chris is several step ahead of everyone else. He has also said that Katherine is already a star. I think they are the two to beat.

[bigd13]

Taylor, Paris, Mandisa, and Elliot need to leave NOW!!
They cant sing at all and I dont know why America has kept them here instead of Ayla and Lisa! As far as I'm concerned Ace, Chris, and Kathrine are my top 3!!!! Ace should WIN!!

You are so **** stupid, Paris sounded the best last night, she messed up a little bit, but was good overall. This is like the 2nd time Ace actually sounded good through the whole competition and now you all up his a**. Katharine sounded like she was going to bring it, but she didn't, I waiting for her to wow me and she hasn't and probably never will. I with you on Chris, he should win, but hello Mandisa, sounded good last night, and Elliot has one of the best voices, it's just that he can't project it like some of the people can.
I am like so mad that you said these people should leave, if they leave the show would suck and what about Bucky and Kellie, they sounded alright, but they suck most of the time. Looking at overall star quality, commanding the stage, and voice ability, Chris, Mandisa, Paris, and Elliot are the best there period. Hell of a lot better than Katharine. I'm looking at overall star ability and Katharine does not have it.

[Helen]

I would say, Mandisa, Elliot, Paris and maybe Ace. I did like him, but not Taylor, his line was busy all night and so was Buckys till much later. I did not try Mandisa cause I did not want to vote for her. I did vote for Elliot cause I think he needs more time to better himself

[loveidol]

I thnk Ace is going to be in the bottom three

[tinsong]

Taylor, Paris, Mandisa, and Elliot need to leave NOW!!
They cant sing at all and I dont know why America has kept them here instead of Ayla and Lisa! As far as I'm concerned Ace, Chris, and Kathrine are my top 3!!!! Ace should WIN!!
Well, I don't think Ace has a chance to win (come on now, he's been in the bottom 3 how many times?) as long as TAYLOR (who CAN INDEED SING, by the way), Chris and Katharine are in this competition. I think the bottom 3 just might be Bucky, Mandisa & Paris tonight. We'll see............

[tinsong]

I would say, Mandisa, Elliot, Paris and maybe Ace. I did like him, but not Taylor, his line was busy all night and so was Buckys till much later. I did not try Mandisa cause I did not want to vote for her. I did vote for Elliot cause I think he needs more time to better himself
I don't think Taylor will be in the bottom 3 either (going by the phone lines). It took me two hours to get 26 votes in for him (considering at one time - early in the competition I've voted as many as 105 for him). I voted for only 3 - Taylor (26), Katharine (30) - her line was busy, too and Elliott (30). That's not[I] saying I don't think any of the others are good, but I did what everybody needs to do - I voted for the ones I desperately want to go on.........
By the way, Helen - do you by chance live in Highpoint, NC?

[Pick_Pickler]

hmmm... that's weird... the didn't Simon already say that Elliot was the best contestant YET?


and we all know that paris will get a contract no matter how she does on here.


and you have to give some respect to mandisa... look how confident and amazing she is. and that voice kicks some serious butt, too.


and taylor will be in the top three, more than likely. the american populous doesn't always have to have someone who follows the norm for their American Idol. and taylor portrays that image VERY well.

this isn't Beauty and the Geek.

I know I'm shallow, but if you actually kicked her butt, it'd wobble like jelly for the next hour and you would fall up her ass.

On the subject, no, I mostly don't agree. Paris, best vocalist I've ever seen on Idol, excluding Kelly Clarkson. Taylor is great, could sell millions of records in a week or so, Elliot is the best male vocalist, but Mandisa, I think she is too over-the-top and boring for me, heck, if she went missing, you'd have to use all four sides of the milk carton (Source of joke: VFTW Forum)

[ms_suzyq_2u]

My bottom three:

1) Bucky
2) Mandisa (I'm sad about that one)
3) Ace

[idolsmidol]

Innocent Dreamer you were right!! Mandisa, Elliott and Paris were in the final three. I find it hard to believe that Elliott is in this group though. He has performed really well in the last two weeks.

[idolsmidol]

Kudos to you too Helen. You were right on the money!!

[cinnamocha]

I would say, Mandisa, Elliot, Paris and maybe Ace. I did like him, but not Taylor, his line was busy all night and so was Buckys till much later. I did not try Mandisa cause I did not want to vote for her. I did vote for Elliot cause I think he needs more time to better himself


Wow that was a great guess! This week was tough, it didn't know who the bottom three would be. I am happy with Americas desicion!
: :o :p

[Helen]

No, I do not, I actually live near Hershey, Pa in a town by the name of Lebanon, dutch country, or dutchified country and good food. I have family living South in Bradenton/Sarasota area. I liked the going off choice tonight if that is a happy night, which it is not. I was fearful for Elliot. Thinking Paris, but she has a better voice the Mandisa in overall songs

[biggamejames]

Sorry but you simply must be kidding or you do not understand anything about music and sing... Mandisa has one of the best voices ever in AI competition, as well as Paris, who is amazing for her age... and Elliot is really a better singer than Ace. Ok, Ace is a very handsome guy with a good voice, and it is ok to want to see him as the next American Idol, but please you do not need to say foolish things like "They cant sing at all"... because they really can sing, a lot! I think that Chris is the one who deserve to win this edition, but it cannot make me deaf and blind to the talent of the other contestants.

I agree with you. No way does Ace belong to the Top 3; as much as he's got an all around package, vocally he's limited... plus he's only got that falsetto and "smoldering towards the camera LOOK" going for him; he's lucky he looks that way cause he aint got the chops to be the next A.I.

I agree Chris is fantastic, but I also like Katharine and Elliot. Too bad about Mandisa because, although she's not my favorite, she's got a fantastic voice.

[Angel]

ACE should win a beauty contest, not American Idol. Once again America is voting with its eyes and not their ears. ACE cracks, often. His range is weak and he shakes when he performs. Elliot and Mandissa have more talent in their right toe. But, Mandissa will leave because of her weight and someone like ACE will stay with his weak vocals, because he is gorgeous. I mean even his brothers are gorgeous, but this isn't a beauty contest. Elliot has really stepped up his performance and he is getting stronger and stronger ever weak, I'd love to him in the final three. I like Chris, but sometimes he does more shouting than singing. And Kellie and Bucky need to go Nashville Star, because all they can sing is country and they are good at what they do, well their better than most, and American Idol was intended for the "Pop" culture and a more diverse range of talent.