View Full Version : Could Kat Be Leaving??
COUNTRYGIRL
03-29-2006, 02:12 PM
I read on another idol forum today that tonight may be a shocker and tonight could be Katharine's farewell.
That would definately be shocking and hope that someone is badly mistaken!! :argue:
AbsentElement
03-29-2006, 02:19 PM
The shocker won't be Kat going home. It'll be no surprise who goes home, Lisa (okay, MAYBE Kellie, but doubt it). The shocker will be that Bucky avoids the bottom three alltogether.
cloie4me
03-29-2006, 02:44 PM
I hope Bucky avoids the bottom 3 this week. I know he will leave soon but I think this was his best week ever.
IdolMe
03-29-2006, 02:56 PM
The shocker won't be Kat going home. It'll be no surprise who goes home, Lisa (okay, MAYBE Kellie, but doubt it). The shocker will be that Bucky avoids the bottom three alltogether.
I'm thinking some of the people that were voting for Kevin might be voting for Kellie now.... source: my 6 year old daughter. ;)
cloie4me
03-29-2006, 03:08 PM
I'm thinking some of the people that were voting for Kevin might be voting for Kellie now.... source: my 6 year old daughter. ;)
I was asking that question myself. I feel with each contestant leaving, another is getting stronger (because they are getting their votes.) I think if Lisa goes home Paris will get her votes.
AbsentElement
03-29-2006, 03:09 PM
I'm thinking some of the people that were voting for Kevin might be voting for Kellie now.... source: my 6 year old daughter. ;)
true, and she has the votefortheworst following on her side.
frank
03-29-2006, 06:53 PM
I read on another idol forum today that tonight may be a shocker and tonight could be Katharine's farewell.
That would definately be shocking and hope that someone is badly mistaken!! :argue:
That will never happen,....the producers will not let that happen, votes or no votes. :eek:
frank
03-29-2006, 08:38 PM
That will never happen,....the producers will not let that happen, votes or no votes. :eek:
I told you that they wouldn't let her go. Have you ever wondered who leaks these "Big Surprises"? I'm telling you the shows producers are pulling the strings on this competition. The one funny thing that I noticed was how pissed Kat looked. I could just hear her thinking..."HOW DARE THEY PUT ME IN THE BOTTOM THREE"!!!
Ciuma
03-29-2006, 09:02 PM
How on earth do you conceive of the idea that Katharine looked pissed? Do you somehow think she's pissed just because she's not giddy? It's interesting how she and Lisa were both smiling a lot. I guess maybe Katharine was laughing because she was badly in need of some endorphins. And Ace was grave as ever.
When I was waiting for the final result, I just thought: "You know, I'm going to buy Katharine's CD either way (and she'd bloody well better have one), so screw America." If Katharine leaves before making the top five, I doubt I'll be able to let myself continue watching the show. I'd just be too sad and disgusted to pay any attention to the others.
Who got voted off?? I didn't get to see the results. :confused:
Ciuma
03-29-2006, 09:12 PM
That would be Lisa.
I'm starting to wonder if it isn't that six-year-old type who owns the largest share of the show. I don't even think six-year-old kids need to be voting. They can barely talk yet.
I figured she would be next because no one really talks about her. Thanks!
Son of Simon
03-29-2006, 09:21 PM
Wow- and so the Macpheever chills. Maybe she'll see this as a lesson to be aware of what people are saying about her "arrogance".
In related news- Bucky wins American Idol!
In less related news- "Larry the Cable Guy" wins the American presidential election, with his running mate, Jeff Foxworthy.
I shouldn't have said that aloud...hopefully I didn't begin the apocalypse!!!
COUNTRYGIRL
03-30-2006, 06:57 AM
Lisa got voted out. The bottom three were Lisa, Ace and Katharine.
Ciuma, you shouldn't put all your eggs in one basket. I'm not going to loose any sleep over any of them getting voted out (not saying that you are). At this point anyone can win. Though I have my favoirtes, if they don't make it, I'll still watch and be happy for the winner. I may not agree with the choice but that's life.
I didn't think that Kat looked pissed, it was more like surprised to me. "How could this happen after Simon made my head so big??"
I think Ace was sweating bullets and Lisa, well she should have seen it coming.
froggiegurl
03-30-2006, 08:59 AM
i was soo mad when i saw katharine in the bottom three. she really didnt deserve that. i think it should have been bucky or kellie in her place.
mustlovechihuahuas
03-30-2006, 09:08 AM
Was Lisa really that bad? I have read comments that she is awful, she has weird eyebrows, mean looks, etc. I just don't see any of that. She is only 16, and I think she has a powerful voice. Repeat - powerful voice. - not scream, scream, screaming voice. (referring to Mandisa)
Bucky looked as surprised as anyone when Katharine was in the bottom three. Kellie was safe from the get go., I guess. Paris sings so effortlessly, I still think she has a shot at it....second ..though to my main man...Chris. Ok, I know, he screamed Tuesday night. Made a vein in his forehead pop out.....but he will do better next Tuesday.
froggiegurl
03-30-2006, 09:18 AM
well, lisa isnt all that bad but she ruined "because of you". i really wouldnt suggest doing a former idols' song. you have a lot to live up to doing a kelly clarkson song.
bucky was suprised, i think he thought that he was in the bottom three over katharine (which he should have been).
Feisty Kitty
03-30-2006, 12:48 PM
First order of business: LOL, Son of Simon!!! I also made a reference to Kat in the bottom 3 being a sign of the apocalypse in another thread. We think alike!
Secondly: I AM HOPPING MAD!!! How could Katherine be in the bottom two? It is the end of all I have ever believed in, (such as people voting for the best singer in a singing competition)? What is wrong with these people? She is the best! The best of the best!!!!!!!!!!
And friggin' Kellie was SAFE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
AAAAHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
If Kat goes, I go, COLD TURKEY!!! No more AI for me!
tinsong
03-30-2006, 12:56 PM
I told you that they wouldn't let her go. Have you ever wondered who leaks these "Big Surprises"? I'm telling you the shows producers are pulling the strings on this competition. The one funny thing that I noticed was how pissed Kat looked. I could just hear her thinking..."HOW DARE THEY PUT ME IN THE BOTTOM THREE"!!!
Whew! Was that a shocker! I think her look was more that of SHOCK than pissed. It so reminded me of last year when Constantine was voted off. Let's hope she picks a really good country song for next week - like Martina's 'Independence Day'?
froggiegurl
03-30-2006, 01:06 PM
First order of business: LOL, Son of Simon!!! I also made a reference to Kat in the bottom 3 being a sign of the apocalypse in another thread. We think alike!
Secondly: I AM HOPPING MAD!!! How could Katherine be in the bottom two? It is the end of all I have ever believed in, (such as people voting for the best singer in a singing competition)? What is wrong with these people? She is the best! The best of the best!!!!!!!!!!
And friggin' Kellie was SAFE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
AAAAHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
If Kat goes, I go, COLD TURKEY!!! No more AI for me!
i so totally agree with you. if katharine is gone there is no reason to watch ai anymore.
ms_suzyq_2u
04-01-2006, 03:32 PM
Whew! Was that a shocker! I think her look was more that of SHOCK than pissed. It so reminded me of last year when Constantine was voted off. Let's hope she picks a really good country song for next week - like Martina's 'Independence Day'?
I agree that it was a shock that Katherine was in the bottom three but it's too late for her to grow a personality now! She has a GREAT voice but, unfortunately for her, so do many of the other contestants - and they have personalities! This is supposed to be a singing competition but if the person is not likeable they will not win!
The cutesy, act dumb part is already taken by a couple other contestants. Katherine would win if she could form a sentance and present it in an intelligent manner - with NO GIGGLING!
graciespeaks
04-03-2006, 06:16 PM
Whew! Was that a shocker! I think her look was more that of SHOCK than pissed. It so reminded me of last year when Constantine was voted off. Let's hope she picks a really good country song for next week - like Martina's 'Independence Day'?
Actually I saw ALOT of "pissed" in her mother's face, but for a second I did see a look of " I'm mad" from her
All in All she was clearly uncomfortable.
Lisa showed more humility I thought, but that could have been due to "experience".
cloie4me
04-03-2006, 06:54 PM
First order of business: LOL, Son of Simon!!! I also made a reference to Kat in the bottom 3 being a sign of the apocalypse in another thread. We think alike!
Secondly: I AM HOPPING MAD!!! How could Katherine be in the bottom two? It is the end of all I have ever believed in, (such as people voting for the best singer in a singing competition)? What is wrong with these people? She is the best! The best of the best!!!!!!!!!!
And friggin' Kellie was SAFE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
AAAAHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
If Kat goes, I go, COLD TURKEY!!! No more AI for me!
If more thought like you and had your taste, she wouldnt have been in the botton 2. But since we all have our favorites, you might see her again in the bottom three. Whats wrong with us? different taste, thats all