Kelly Clarkson's voice

[AngusN]

After watching Kelly's dreadful performance on Idol Gives Back, it is clear that the vocal style of her songs is not doing her voice any favours. Her performance was rough; she shouted her way through the more powerful notes and her voice clearly cracked at one point. She needs to take more care of her instrument, otherwise it will burn out.

n.b And what was that maternity dress she was wearing? Sorry Kelly I think you're great, but you were awful, in more ways than one on that show.

[RushDog]

*Crickets*

I think you're alone in that assessment.

[Sanjayalicious]

i didnt watch that part of the show, so i didn't see or hear her:(

[Sanjayalicious]

in fact, ive never seen or heard Kelly anywhere after she won idol:confused:

[SlighDawg]

Oh she's all over the place. Isn't she the most successful idol?

Well, now probably Carrie is, but she was the most successful.

[RushDog]

Kelly has a new CD out. I do have her 'Breakaway' CD. It's purty good!

[SlighDawg]

It's amazing how much they've all changed. Here is her original audition. Randy auditioned too. I forgot about that. Simon had poofy hair, and Kelly was a bad dresser.
http://youtube.com/watch?v=46nTI_E5TZ8

[RushDog]

Score!

Simon looks like one of the Pet Shop Boys.

[SlighDawg]

I loved that song "West End Girls"

[RushDog]

I loved that song "West End Girls"

Yeah, reminds me of when I was stationed in England. They played that song alot in the clubs.

[SlighDawg]

They did here too. ;)

[Eileenacanadian]

I loved that song "West End Girls"

Brings back excellent memories!

[RushDog]

Brings back excellent memories!

Sure does. Those were some good times.

[SlighDawg]

That's why I love that m&m's commercial with the The The song in it. "This is the day, your life will surely change"

Great stuff!

[Mister_J]

Kelly Clarkson put on a very good performance on Idol Gives Back. She reminded me of Janis Joplin a little bit. I think she's found her calling now. I even thought she was better than Annie Lennox.

[yayamiddlesister]

Awesome performance by Kelly!

[RushDog]

Awesome performance by Kelly!

I thought so too.

[TaylorHicksRocks]

Kelly Clarkson put on a very good performance on Idol Gives Back. She reminded me of Janis Joplin a little bit. I think she's found her calling now. I even thought she was better than Annie Lennox.

You got that right Mister J! Annie should have stayed home....

[laraine]

I thought Kelly was pretty pants too, she looks like she's gained a few pounds which probably accounts for the dress.

[RushDog]

Pretty pants?:confused:

The dress just made her look big.

[Mister_J]

You got that right Mister J! Annie should have stayed home....

I think i would've even did a better job! :p

[Sanjayalicious]

HI Mister_J!!! :D

[Mister_J]

HI Mister_J!!! :D

hey Licious! :p

[laraine]

well in England, if something is pants, it means its pretty cr*p. I thought Kelly's arms looked a little chubby too, but the dress certainly did nothing for her at all.

[RushDog]

well in England, if something is pants, it means its pretty cr*p. I thought Kelly's arms looked a little chubby too, but the dress certainly did nothing for her at all.

I thought she sounded great. I didn't think she looked bad at all.

[TaylorHicksRocks]

I think i would've even did a better job! :p

I am certain you would have done a better job.....;)

[Mister_J]

I am certain you would have done a better job.....;)

i'll sing for lemonade! lol :p

[TaylorHicksRocks]

i'll sing for lemonade! lol :p

Well it's in the 80's here today perfect for lemonade.....we could even charge folks to listen to your fantastic voice....Now that's a great idea...
Hehehe

[AngusN]

Kelly sounded dreadful, her voice was hoarse and as I pointed out before, she cracked in the middle of a held note. She is not the vocal performer that woman American Idol. I thought she was dreadful! Clearly all the indie style pop songs she has taken to singing are ruining her voice.

[chrisalltheway]

After watching Kelly's dreadful performance on Idol Gives Back, it is clear that the vocal style of her songs is not doing her voice any favours. Her performance was rough; she shouted her way through the more powerful notes and her voice clearly cracked at one point. She needs to take more care of her instrument, otherwise it will burn out.

n.b And what was that maternity dress she was wearing? Sorry Kelly I think you're great, but you were awful, in more ways than one on that show.
Really? I thought she was quite good. Did'nt like the dress though.

[chrisalltheway]

in fact, ive never seen or heard Kelly anywhere after she won idol:confused:
Do you live under a rock?

[chrisalltheway]

I am certain you would have done a better job.....;)
How do you know Mister J?

[TaylorHicksRocks]

How do you know Mister J?

Just through PM's and chatting on the forums he is a really cool guy!!! If I were just a bit younger i would be after that tall gorgeous man!;)

[Mister_J]

Just through PM's and chatting on the forums he is a really cool guy!!! If I were just a bit younger i would be after that tall gorgeous man!;)

i like older women anyways :p

[SlighDawg]

Just through PM's and chatting on the forums he is a really cool guy!!! If I were just a bit younger i would be after that tall gorgeous man!;)

If he's tall and gorgeous and likes older women... HAY MISTER JAYYYY! ;)

[RushDog]

well in England, if something is pants, it means its pretty cr*p. I thought Kelly's arms looked a little chubby too, but the dress certainly did nothing for her at all.


Kelly sounded dreadful, her voice was hoarse and as I pointed out before, she cracked in the middle of a held note. She is not the vocal performer that woman American Idol. I thought she was dreadful! Clearly all the indie style pop songs she has taken to singing are ruining her voice.

Well, I guess you Brits hear things differently than we do.

[RushDog]

in fact, ive never seen or heard Kelly anywhere after she won idol:confused:

Yeah, she hasn't done much. She only won two grammy awards for her Breakaway album. Breakaway won in the "Best Pop Vocal Album" category and the single "Since U Been Gone" received the "Best Female Pop Vocal Performance" award. The album only sold over 11 million worldwide.

Do you have electricity?

[janetodd38]

Yeah, she hasn't done much. She only won two grammy awards for her Breakaway album. Breakaway won in the "Best Pop Vocal Album" category and the single "Since U Been Gone" received the "Best Female Pop Vocal Performance" award. The album only sold over 11 million worldwide.

Do you have electricity?

Well it's obvious Sanjayalicious doesn't have both oars in the water. Anybody that idolizes Sanji that much needs check-up from the neck-up.

He seems like some 12 year old banging on daddy's keyboard when he should be in school. :D

[Mister_J]

If he's tall and gorgeous and likes older women... HAY MISTER JAYYYY! ;)

hey Sligh!!! :p Are you excited about Bon Jovi tonight? I know i am! This might be the best night all season. :boldblue:

[AngusN]

Well, I guess you Brits hear things differently than we do.


No, we're just honest (Simon Cowell). We don't sugar-coat things (Paula Abdul).

[SlighDawg]

Well it's obvious Sanjayalicious doesn't have both oars in the water. Anybody that idolizes Sanji that much needs check-up from the neck-up.

He seems like some 12 year old banging on daddy's keyboard when he should be in school. :D
Actually, 'lish is a pretty bright almost college kid who will be going to a pretty good school next year and working on some pretty tough majors. (Once she decides what to choose). Oh, and he's a she who tells it like it is. I don't diss people for having opinions.
hey Sligh!!! :p Are you excited about Bon Jovi tonight? I know i am! This might be the best night all season. :boldblue:
I AM excited! I can't wait to see Bon Jovi's BUTT! <squeeeeling like a little girl> :love:

[Sanjayalicious]

Do you live under a rock?

yes, i do:11doh:

[Sanjayalicious]

If he's tall and gorgeous and likes older women... HAY MISTER JAYYYY! ;)

LOL!!!!
:yelrotflm

[Sanjayalicious]

Yeah, she hasn't done much. She only won two grammy awards for her Breakaway album. Breakaway won in the "Best Pop Vocal Album" category and the single "Since U Been Gone" received the "Best Female Pop Vocal Performance" award. The album only sold over 11 million worldwide.

Do you have electricity?

Maybe, i wasn't that into POP?!?!?!?!?:moon:
i heard "Since you been Gone" a few times, but thats about it:rolleyes:
i didn't buy a copy, i don't know anyone who did.

[Mister_J]

Kelly put Annie Lennox to shame! I like Annie but she should've sang another song. I'm still in disbelief that Clay Aiken didn't make an appearance. He's usually all over these "help the world" campaigns. I hope those kids get something to eat over there. It was very heartbreaking to sit there and watch these kids suffering. They deserve a better life!

[RushDog]

Kelly put Annie Lennox to shame! I like Annie but she should've sang another song. I'm still in disbelief that Clay Aiken didn't make an appearance.

Gayken has made enough appearances to last a lifetime. I can endure Annie butchering that song, if it means I don't have to watch him.

[RushDog]

Maybe, i wasn't that into POP?!?!?!?!?:moon:
i heard "Since you been Gone" a few times, but thats about it:rolleyes:
i didn't buy a copy, i don't know anyone who did.

I guess you don't know many people then.

Maybe if she put out a rap cd, you would've heard it.

[Sanjayalicious]

Well it's obvious Sanjayalicious doesn't have both oars in the water. Anybody that idolizes Sanji that much needs check-up from the neck-up.

He seems like some 12 year old banging on daddy's keyboard when he should be in school. :D

OMG!!!! What is this "Piss on 'Lish" Day?!?!?!:mad:
you are starting to get on my nerves, have i insulted you?

I luv Sanjaya, but i don't worship him and i rarely think about him or any other star unless the subject is brought up, or im on this site!:p My screen name is Sanjayalicious! what else do you think i came here to talk about?

You couldn't be more wrong, here's why:
1)There is nothing wrong with my head. Expressing my love of Sanjaya doesn't make me an idiot. Im smart enough to know that praising what i do like(sanjaya) is more productive than b*tchin about what i dont like.(what you're doing)
2)im not 12, dont assume that you know me
3)Im not using daddy's keyboard, i dont have a daddy.
4)if I were supposed to be in school, i'd be in school.:cool:

[RushDog]

OMG!!!! What is this "Piss on 'Lish" Day?!?!?!:mad:
you are starting to get on my nerves, have i insulted you?

I luv Sanjaya, but i don't worship him and i rarely think about him or any other star unless the subject is brought up, or im on this site!:p My screen name is Sanjayalicious! what else do you think i came here to talk about?

You couldn't be more wrong, here's why:
1)There is nothing wrong with my head. Expressing my love of Sanjaya doesn't make me an idiot. Im smart enough to know that praising what i do like(sanjaya) is more productive than b*tchin about what i dont like.(what you're doing)
2)im not 12, dont assume that you know me
3)Im not using daddy's keyboard, i dont have a daddy.
4)if I were supposed to be in school, i'd be in school.:cool:

You forgot to mention that you're not a guy. LOL

[Sanjayalicious]

I guess you don't know many people then.

Maybe if she put out a rap cd, you would've heard it.

I know plenty of people:p.None of them ever mention Kelly Clarkson, or listen to her music.
Yes, i have a very diverse group of friends, No i don't only listen to Rap:smilies3:
Maybe she should try to broaden her audience to people in an urban community. I listen to every type of music, some, I haven't seen her in MTV?:confused:

[Sanjayalicious]

You forgot to mention that you're not a guy. LOL

that should be obvious:rolleyes: If she hasn't read enough of my posts to tell that, then she shouldn't try to sum me up, like she knows what she's talkin about

[RushDog]

I know plenty of people:p.None of them ever mention Kelly Clarkson, or listen to her music.
Yes, i have a very diverse group of friends, No i don't only listen to Rap:smilies3:
Maybe she should try to broaden her audience to people in an urban community. I listen to every type of music, some, I haven't seen her in MTV?:confused:

Helloooo! The album has gone multi-platinum, and won two Grammies. Why would she need to broaden her audience, when it's already huge?

[RushDog]

that should be obvious:rolleyes: If she hasn't read enough of my posts to tell that, then she shouldn't try to sum me up, like she knows what she's talkin about

Obviously, not obvious to everyone.

[Mister_J]

Clay would have stolen the show if he was there! I believe he's the best male contestant to ever appear on American Idol. He definately wins me over when he sings oldies.

[RushDog]

Clay would have stolen the show if he was there! I believe he's the best male contestant to ever appear on American Idol. He definately wins me over when he sings oldies.

Excuse me, while I vomit.:throwup:

Yeah, he would've stolen the show alright, with his flamboyant self.

[Mister_J]

Excuse me, while I vomit.:throwup:

Yeah, he would've stolen the show alright, with his flamboyant self.

blah. You're just bitter because Taylor upstaged Kat last season. I'm an easy target since i like Taylor and Clay. It doesn't really bother me though. Different strokes for different folks!

[RushDog]

blah. You're just bitter because Taylor upstaged Kat last season. I'm an easy target since i like Taylor and Clay. It doesn't really bother me though. Different strokes for different folks!


Actually I liked Taylor too. I was actually torn because I liked both him and Kat. I just think his CD sucks. He would've been better off not winning, so he could do his own thing. He's a blues singer, not a pop star.

The only person I didn't like last year was Chris, and he'll probably be the most successful one of the bunch.

[SlighDawg]

Clay would have stolen the show if he was there! I believe he's the best male contestant to ever appear on American Idol. He definately wins me over when he sings oldies.

Jay has a very loose terminology there.... not about the best or the contestant part.... ahem.