View Full Version : Tonights show a bummer
Helen
03-28-2006, 08:20 PM
I did not like the show tonight or the pick of the songs. The judges were pretty much on track and Simon also. I liked Lisa and the way she sang her song. I would vote for Taylor and Elliot, as I want them to stay in the top. Chris screamed and Mandisa yelled, not good song picks at all.
IdolManInLove
03-28-2006, 08:26 PM
I agree - the song choices were poor! Chris was so LOUD!. :eek:
m070298
03-28-2006, 08:28 PM
I agree with you. I thought Taylor, Katherine, and believe it or not Bucky sounded better tonight than normal, not great, just better.
But Chris, I'm tired of the screaming, I know he can do that, but I would like to hear something like a ballad, Even "rock" stars sing ballads.
Getting bored with him
Cant stand Kelli, not sure why she is there
disapointed in Mandisa, usually like her
Ace wasn't bad.
But I'm guessing bottom 3: Bucky, Lisa, & Ace: just going by how its been... Bucky, probably next to go.... But I sure wish it was Kelli
cherryd
03-28-2006, 09:49 PM
Yeah Kelly is not that great, I don't know why they brag on her as much as they do. I like Paris. I think she is cute and can sing great.
Kristi_M
03-28-2006, 10:20 PM
Most of the performances were bad...Simon was mostly correct Katharine was whiny and seemed to be off key; Chris's performance was "over-the-top, Mandisa (Mandiva???) was awful (scream ,scream, scream); I didn't like her pandering to the religious croud, either. Kellie was boring. Worst, though, was Lisa...she needs to leave.
I was pleasantly surprized by Bucky, Elliot was good, but the "bouncing" was obnoxious. Taylor probably gave the best performance of the night (Paris was good, but the "cutsie attitude" just kills it for her).
cloie4me
03-28-2006, 10:24 PM
I always vote for Chris, Taylor, and Ace but I think Bucky did HIS finest performance tonight. I also liked Mandisa singing a gospel song. I was hoping she would.
laraine
03-29-2006, 05:29 AM
well thats the kiss of death for Bucky then, being his best performance, last week Kevin went, on his best performance, so it looks like the end of the road for Bucky.
IdolMe
03-29-2006, 05:42 AM
well thats the kiss of death for Bucky then, being his best performance, last week Kevin went, on his best performance, so it looks like the end of the road for Bucky.
yep.. too funny. I agree with "cloie4me" Bucky had a good night but you never know who might go.
Who got all of Kevin's votes???
laraine
03-29-2006, 05:46 AM
yep.. too funny. I agree with "cloie4me" Bucky had a good night but you never know who might go.
Who got all of Kevin's votes???
I don't know, same as Melissa's voters, who are they now supporting? :confused:
mustlovechihuahuas
03-29-2006, 08:17 AM
I thought he looked great in the cowboy hat. I even liked the song.
I was so syched up for the Tuesday night show.....then....what a disappointment!!!! My main man, Chris, even disappointed me. The only one who I was impressed with, I guess, was Paris.
grania
03-29-2006, 09:24 AM
You ask "who got all of Kevin's votes?"
That's my thought, too. The people who leave now all have a fan base, that will go somewhere. Elliot danced my prom date in HS....that might have been a hoot enough to get some of those votes. Paris is real versatile.
It'll be interesting to see. If Bucky gets another week, he might be back in there.
Gosh....this speculation is fun!
grania
03-29-2006, 09:25 AM
That is Elliot danced LIKE my prom date in HS....duh.
froggiegurl
03-29-2006, 09:28 AM
i really was dissapointed by chris too. he needs to stop doing the rock songs. he needs to choose different songs.
katharine started off rocky but in the end it was pretty good
paris was really good. im enjoyed her performance very much.
bucky was actually pretty good. i didnt think he could do a tim mcgraw song
tinsong
03-29-2006, 09:47 AM
I couldn't wait for last night's show - and then what a disappointment in most of their song choices! Taylor out-performed everybody (that's my opinion), but he's done that every week and I honestly think he'll go all the way. I think Lisa, Kellie and either Ace or Bucky will be in the bottom 3. Bucky did good, though - I thought. I am proud of Mandisa for singing a gospel song (although most people, I'm sure, will respond differently). Katharine is another of my favorites. I agree - Chris screamed his performance! I didn't like it. TAYLOR HICKS IS MY PICK!!!!!! When you got it, you got it!!
laraine
03-29-2006, 09:54 AM
I couldn't wait for last night's show - and then what a disappointment in most of their song choices! Taylor out-performed everybody (that's my opinion), but he's done that every week and I honestly think he'll go all the way. I think Lisa, Kellie and either Ace or Bucky will be in the bottom 3. Bucky did good, though - I thought. I am proud of Mandisa for singing a gospel song (although most people, I'm sure, will respond differently). Katharine is another of my favorites. I agree - Chris screamed his performance! I didn't like it. TAYLOR HICKS IS MY PICK!!!!!! When you got it, you got it!!
yeh PICK HICKS!! (as opposed to pick pickler) :D
DeputyDawg
03-29-2006, 12:43 PM
Mandisa sucked. Simon was right, it was self-indulgent and I think she needs to calm down or she's out.
Paris is a freak. Kellie is a freak. Bucky is nearing freakness.
Elliott, Taylor and Chris were great.
Just one person's opinion...
chas_21000
03-29-2006, 01:40 PM
I agree with everyone on this. Chris is loud and scary, Paris was okay but has done much better, Kellie was just terrible, and for Lisa I don't know what she was thinking about. Bucky I really liked his performance he done the best so far for him. Taylor was great I liked how he let us hear his vocals again and not just the dancing end of it. Tonight is going to be interesting cause really I don't know normally I can guess the bottom 3 and be right but tonight I have two or three thought on who could go home.
My guess is either Lisa, Kellie, or Bucky even though I don't what Bucky to leave just yet. I can't wait till Kellie goes home though
cloie4me
03-29-2006, 02:51 PM
well thats the kiss of death for Bucky then, being his best performance, last week Kevin went, on his best performance, so it looks like the end of the road for Bucky.
You are funny, enjoyed the laugh.
cloie4me
03-29-2006, 02:52 PM
I agree with everyone on this. Chris is loud and scary, Paris was okay but has done much better, Kellie was just terrible, and for Lisa I don't know what she was thinking about. Bucky I really liked his performance he done the best so far for him. Taylor was great I liked how he let us hear his vocals again and not just the dancing end of it. Tonight is going to be interesting cause really I don't know normally I can guess the bottom 3 and be right but tonight I have two or three thought on who could go home.
My guess is either Lisa, Kellie, or Bucky even though I don't what Bucky to leave just yet. I can't wait till Kellie goes home though
I agree with everything you said. Good insight.