I was banned from the Kellie Pickler site...

[tulawdog]

...simply because I asked if anyone thought she was dumb as dirt. I love her. I didn't say I thought she was dumb as dirt. I just wanted to know if anyone else thought that and they banned me. ;)

[Dillion]

...simply because I asked if anyone thought she was dumb as dirt. I love her. I didn't say I thought she was dumb as dirt. I just wanted to know if anyone else thought that and they banned me. ;)

That's too bad. :( But cool that you are here now. The owner here is way cool and I doubt he would do that.

[cypress]

I don't buy into Kellie. She's from North Carolina and has never had a Spinach Salad? I understand not tasting or eating Caaaalllll-Ar-Marrri, but it's not foreign on a menu, especially places like Cheesecake factory or Olive Garden. She acted like she never heard of these things before her trip to Hollywood. Contrived.

[IdolMe]

...simply because I asked if anyone thought she was dumb as dirt. I love her. I didn't say I thought she was dumb as dirt. I just wanted to know if anyone else thought that and they banned me. ;)

You are welcome here tuladog. :)

The great thing about forums is people can speak there mind online here... for everyone to read.

[AlwaysL8]

Aparently, you have never been to Albemarle, North Carolina - I know there's a Wal-Mart, but not even sure there's a McDonalds... There is that possiblity that she genuinely has never heard of some of these places. We don't all live in the "big city".

Kudos to her for making it to this point. I respect her.

[tulawdog]

Even if the stories are true, they just sound so contrived. As I've said, I love Kellie, but I wish she'd ease up on the comments like...

"Ah'd eat me sum more of that callie-marrie if it'll keep me here longer."

[jig10j]

Does anyone besides myself not see the appeal of Kellie Pickler. She's cute, blonde and has a country twang, but come on. She has minor talent and I think she's playing the niave country bumpkin thing up a little much. It's like Carrie Underwood without the vocal chops.

[Dakota]

hahahahahah...that really cracked me up...you made my day

[jig10j]

I don't mean to hate on her but being cute with a home life that plays out like a bad country song doesn't make you a good singer. Maybe she should write songs about her life experience, but let someone else sing them.

[PeopleSuck]

I love Kellie,she is so adorable & seems like a real sweety.Dont see how ppl could dislike her :confused:

[jig10j]

I don't dislike her but the 'oh i'm so country and dumb and cute' act just gets on my nerves. She's more likeable than Carrie Underwood though and way hotter. The record company will eat her alive without the right people around her.

[PeopleSuck]

Im afraid that if she does win or if she lands a deal down the road,that because she is so naive ppl will take advantage of that.She is too sheltered for the real world & I hope she learns how to deal w/ it quickly,she seems like such a good person & it would be a shame if she got hurt

[jig10j]

You are so right. Other male artist or movie stars will all want to date her and she'll get passed around and screwed out her royalties by the record company. That is what happens to alot of pretty young girls in that business. She's going to need a good trust worthy team to guide her.

[PeopleSuck]

Yes she will need a trust worthy team around her,lets just hope she gets one!

[Helen]

Hi there, I also was banned, is what I think, cool owner here for sure. I sent an e-mail voicing my opinion on the behavior of the judges last Thursday, got no reply from them, I know they get millions of e-mail. I am not the only person that wrote to the higher ups on the Idol, to be sure. Kelly has to prove her self in the coming weeks. I have not written her off as of yet, I am afraid the guys will be much better and then she does not have to worry about votes.

[jig10j]

People vote for Kellie because of her personality and that's about it. Her singing is not bad but nothing to get excited about. I just hate for some one more talented to get voted off just because she's so perky and it's funny to hear how she doesn't know anything about city life.

[tulawdog]

Greeeeeen acres is the place for Kellie. Faaaarm livin' is the life for her. Land spreadin' out so far and wide. Keep Hollywood, just give 'er that countryside.....

[Lexy]

Greeeeeen acres is the place for Kellie. Faaaarm livin' is the life for her. Land spreadin' out so far and wide. Keep Hollywood, just give 'er that countryside.....

*ROFL* that was waaaaaayyyyyyyyy funny :)

[jig10j]

They should play that song during her interview clips. Too funny.

[sammi2116]

You know...Kellie is cute as a button, and NO, she's definitely not the most talented in the competition. However, between her and the other little chipper girl, they are going to keep us in stitches until we have gotten rid of all the other less talented contestants.

[jig10j]

This week is all Stevie Wonder songs. I don't know how Kellie is going to pull this off but I can just hear her saying " I aint never heard of Steevy Wander Yall" " I didn't know blind folk could sing" Then everyone will laugh and say how cute is she, and she's on to the next week.

[Son of Simon]

Kellie Pickler will end up with a Disney contract- not an AI gig.

Young teens will want to see her on TV, and they won't know enough to distinguish her vocal abilities. Heck...isn't that what we learned from the success of Ashlee Simpson? And she's not even remotely cute...

[Helen]

I like that I never heard of Stevie Wonder. On that note who on the top 12 do you all think will do good with his songs? Songs can make or break. Be fair.

[Don Diego]

Oops! I got them on sale! My shoes I mean. It's contrived and I'm tired of hearing it.

[Helen]

She was quick and witty tonight, singing, as the judges said. The song was a pretty one. Kelli would be good on a sitcom with comedy, or a stand up comedian.

[froggiegurl]

kellie isnt that good of a singer.
she's just cute and likeable

[KONS]

Hi my name is Kons and I'm really stupid and got banned for spamming this forum. I guess I need to look into a new business model since SPAMMING just isn't working out.

[A4ANXIETY]

...simply because I asked if anyone thought she was dumb as dirt. I love her. I didn't say I thought she was dumb as dirt. I just wanted to know if anyone else thought that and they banned me. ;)
I'll say that she acts dumb as dirt.. but it's an act.. & I think the people will soon get sick of her.. I know I am..

[Cageme]

It appears that there is a BIG group who adore Kellie ( Simon among them )
There is also another BIG group that don't enjoy Kellie

Looks like the only group that matters is the one that is VOTING

My personal choice is Mandisa and secondly Paris.

So far I am only voting for my MAN but I will start voting for MANdisa too

[carrierocks]

Aparently, you have never been to Albemarle, North Carolina - I know there's a Wal-Mart, but not even sure there's a McDonalds... There is that possiblity that she genuinely has never heard of some of these places. We don't all live in the "big city".

Kudos to her for making it to this point. I respect her.

Honey look on a map........She is not far fron Charlotte, NC (a very big city...home of Charlotte Panthers). Ive lived not far from where she lives, have many friends in her area and dated a couple of people in her town. They all have there teeth, vote and watch the news. Dont be mislead. SHE'S SMART ENOUGH TO ACT STUPID.
And she does it for people just like you.

[cloie4me]

...simply because I asked if anyone thought she was dumb as dirt. I love her. I didn't say I thought she was dumb as dirt. I just wanted to know if anyone else thought that and they banned me. ;)

How can they do that? I can see if you were using bad language or making x-rated comments, but isnt this forum for peoples thoughts? Not all comments are going to be good, if they were, what would be the point?
The only way I disagree with you is that I dont think she is dumb, I think it is an act to get votes...and its working.

[electrikkblue]

I read that she really isnt dumb, that its an act. She participates in many pagents-on stage yes-AND that she dumbed(LOL) dumped her boyfriend when she made it to Hollywood just to say she was single! Hmmmmm....oh well she still says some cute things but come on....its a little thick Kelly!

[cloie4me]

I read that she really isnt dumb, that its an act. She participates in many pagents-on stage yes-AND that she dumbed(LOL) dumped her boyfriend when she made it to Hollywood just to say she was single! Hmmmmm....oh well she still says some cute things but come on....its a little thick Kelly!


I believe it completely. If she was dumb she would have been dumb earlier in the contest, but she wasnt. It just gets worse each week.

[frank]

I love Kellie,she is so adorable & seems like a real sweety.Dont see how ppl could dislike her :confused:

She is the female version of Forrest Gump. I guess everyone loves Kelli Gump, does that make Ryan Lt. Dan?

Stupid is as stupid does.

[electrikkblue]

LOL..too funny.
I dont know really what to think. Shes something to look at so that will take her a long way. You cant help but think shes the package and she CAN sing so we shall see.
smiles...im gonna go....RUN FORREST RUN!!!! oh i love that movie...

[fswhite]

I think it is really a shame that the majority of voters vote for who is cute or likeable and completely ignaore the vocal talents of the real singers. If Kelly were on The Country Idol show, she would be in top; however her vocals are minimal at best. To compare her with Mandisa or Katherine is laughable. Taylor is fun to watch and probably the underdog of the show because of howhe looks, he's good and I do like him; but again, vocally compared to Mandisa, Katherine, and Paris; he doesn't even come close. Katherine has good vocals, but her vocals remind me of last years winner. There is nothing really spectacular about her, she doesn't really stand out. Taylor at least stands out. If America voted truly for vocals and talent, the top performers would be Mandisa, Paris, Crhis, and Yamin. The rest are just okay. In reality though, I know this is not how America votes. Too bad.

[barbie_09]

opinions seem to be respected here have no worries unless youre over the line.......:)

[IdolMe]

opinions seem to be respected here have no worries unless youre over the line.......:)

yep. that's what forums are all about... discuss away. ;)

We really only moderate/ban a member if they go overboard and use racial or ethnic statements.

I have belonged to a few boards and if the moderators or admin didn't like what you said they would delete your post. Total crap if you ask me.. I want people to have the ability to say what's on their minds... even if we don't agree. ;)

[idolsmidol]

It doesn't matter where Kelli is from. There is television, movies, newspapers, the internet, magazines, school, and any number of other ways to learn about the world around you. The Kelli act indeed grows thin--I hope that she joins Bucky and Lisa in the final three tonight.

Actually, I think she could have a good career as a country and western version of Goldie Hawn. She could be the ditzy blonde on any number of C & W music shows. However the important difference between Goldie and Kellie is that Goldie knows she is acting and is a smart business woman. I honestly think that Kelli thinks she has to act stupid to make it. I feel sorry for her.

As for Simon's prediction of Kelli in the final two, forget about it! I read his book, "I don't mean to be rude..." and he made several predictions --one was that Brad Pitt and Jennifer Anniston were true love and would be toghether forever--That is just one of many predictions he was wrong about.

I like Simon, he tells the truth as he perceives it, but he is wrong about Kelli. She is starting to get on too many peoples' nerves with her dumb yokel routine.