Who do you hate?

[doglover]

Which judge do you hate the most?
I don't know who I really hate, I guess I hate all of them at a time, but after that moment has passed, I get over it.

[Dakota]

Well,I wouldn't say hate. That's way to strong.Perhaps not really great or something like don't care for would be a better choice of words. Just my opinion. But Simon is really not my choice of a good judge. He is being so rude to everyone with his comments. Where does it give a judge the right to slam people about their weight! He should be replaced.We don't need to have people being insulted by him. :talker:

[CINDY]

not to say hate .... but i dun really like Paula and Randy... They always give the same comments. Paula should have expectations and must have her own opinion.

[Jinxies24]

I don't really hate any of them but my least favorite is Randy. I love Simon he is such a blunt person!

[Magicmarkerman]

I like how simon tells it how it is too! Sometimes his attitude can get in the way of fair comment, ut thats him... take the good with the bad. I cant say i hate any of the judges, they all seem to have pretty fair and reasonable input. You got to respect Simons honesty though...Sometimes i think he bases his comments on appearance rather than the vocals... I dont know, but am i the ONLY one that thought Kevin sang REALLY good with his Stevie song?? I was shocked at Simons feedback...kinda goes with my thought of his comments being based on appearance... Cuz I do have to admit, that kid cant move! :)

[laraine]

Ni you're not, I thought he did ok, at least he remembered his lyrics, Melissa can't be shocked that she went home when she couldn't even remember hers. Kevins was a difficult song to sing too, quite fast, although it was nowhere near as good as Nico's version last season, he wasn't the worst on the night.

I like how simon tells it how it is too! Sometimes his attitude can get in the way of fair comment, ut thats him... take the good with the bad. I cant say i hate any of the judges, they all seem to have pretty fair and reasonable input. You got to respect Simons honesty though...Sometimes i think he bases his comments on appearance rather than the vocals... I dont know, but am i the ONLY one that thought Kevin sang REALLY good with his Stevie song?? I was shocked at Simons feedback...kinda goes with my thought of his comments being based on appearance... Cuz I do have to admit, that kid cant move! :)

[Magicmarkerman]

I agree...Kevin wasnt even close to being the worst that night... They all are improving, and with some of the bottom three scares, I think this week will be a great show by everyone! I think they all want it pretty bad now, and they will try to prove it!

[Dakota]

Paula is the one I do not like. She does not have anything to say. She repeates herself. We need another judge.

[idolsmidol]

I think Paula is the worst judge. She acts like she is high--She can talk for ten minutes and says nothing. She offers nothing of value to the contestants, she simply tells each one how much she loves their uniqueness. --

Randy is good, but he tries too hard, and that causes him to name drop about people he knows and has worked with. He should just chill and offer constructive criticism--Also, I am tired of hearing about the dog pound. --

Simon is brutally honest and offers the discerning contestant advice on improving--Besides, he is genuinely funny. If he hurts the feelings of a contestant, he pays for it because he has ditzy Paula right beside him rambling on and on and on.

[futureidol]

Ni you're not, I thought he did ok, at least he remembered his lyrics, Melissa can't be shocked that she went home when she couldn't even remember hers. Kevins was a difficult song to sing too, quite fast, although it was nowhere near as good as Nico's version last season, he wasn't the worst on the night.
yeah Nikko was good. I didnt think kevin was great tho.

[carolyn1721]

i really have a problem with paula, being that she doesn't have the right to judge anyone else's singing when she can't even sing herself. ever since this show has been in creation, i've always felt that she was the wrong person for the job. they should have gotten someone who can REALLY sing, has a strong history of talent and a real voice, instead of picking some fake, lip-sync wannabe who couldn't sing if she actually had a voice. they should have gotten rid of her before she even got started......there's still time to!!!! and if given the opportunity, i'd tell her that myself.

[froggiegurl]

my least favorite judge is paula because she isnt real with the contestants. she just tells them what they wanna hear.

[lexi040704]

Well I don't hate any of them. If any of them were to be off the show, it would not even be worth watching.
They are all completly different and you never know what they are going to say. Simon can be rude, but when he tells someone they are going home, they go home!
I love Randy and Paula!!!!!!!