Of the 4 winners, who's the best..?

[bkk344]

Ok, since Carrie was announced the winner of the 4th season of American Idol, and given the 3 previous winners: Kelly, Ruben, Fantasia.., who is your personal fave from the winner's bracket. My vote goes to Ruben!

[Dakota]

I think Fantasia is the best singer.She has what it takes to get to the top.What would that be "the drive" and it comes from the heart. Yes,she needs the money who dosen't. In my opinion Fantasia is the whole package.I would love to see her perform in Las Vegas. Well ,she would big an even bigger star. They would probably make her a regular performer.The new Wynn Casino would be packed to her sing. I get the chills just listening to her beautiful voice.So everyone ,tell all your friends to go see her in concert in your area. You will not be disappointed.

Dakota :)

[IdolMe]

See I would say Carrie is the whole package. Plus she sings country music and country musicians tend to have longer careers. To me Carrie is the ultimate idol.

[obenix]

I voted for Fantasia... she has a wonderful voice.
Let's face it... we listen to their music and singing... whether they can perform on stage or otherwise is not important to me..
I just want to plug my earphone into my iPod and listen to her sing away...:)

[Jessica17]

Kelly is good and she was the first.

[Lexy]

Carrie and kelly R Ok. I like Clay and anthony they both can sing and R cuties.

[Dakota]

Anthony was the worst. I can't believe he lasted that long.Maybe he lasted so long was the fact all the teeny boopers voted for him.Honestly ,the guy could not sing.Others were getting voted off the show that could sing.What a joke that was.