Let's Petition to Vote OFF a judge during finale

[idolsmidol]

I would like for the AI fans get the opportunity to vote off a judge at the end of each season! That way the good judges could stay, but the bad judge would go home and a replacement would be found--My vote?

No secret--I could do without the incoherent ramblings of Paula. She gives no positive feedback to make the contestants better. Just tells them that they are incredible, have on great looking shoes, etc.

What do you think? Wouldn't AI be a better show if the judges felt some responsibility to be unbiased and show up sober? Who would you vote to leave and why?

[Son of Simon]

Once you get into the late rounds- it would be best to have guest judges.

Especially in light of the fact that Paula and Randy say the same 4 things to any contestant on any given night, and Simon goes from being an honest judge to a "spinster" towards the end, trying to curry favor with the fans even if he doesn't agree with them, and at other times trying to gain/lose votes for contestants he feels are more profitable.

Even if it's the matter of sticking an extra person on that panel eveyr week, at least we'd have something unbiased to listen to.

[lucy]

Even if it's the matter of sticking an extra person on that panel every week, at least we'd have something unbiased to listen to.

We agree Son of Simon, we agree!!! It would give us something different to listen to, some variety!!! Another great plus is that we could throw a few stones their way too!!!! LOL LOL

[Ciuma]

Maybe, SoS... but I always hated the guest judges in previous years. They were all like mild Paulas with nothing interesting to say and mostly just compliments. Obviously afraid to say something bad their one time on the show. But this year the judges have gotten so annoying.. I guess it might have been a good idea after all. But I think they should get seriously qualified judges instead of just famous ones. Being famous doesn't make them good judges. Randy, Paula, and Simon were all already somewhat famous and rich. But I guess they don't want judges who have much at all to say because they wouldn't have time to say it on the show anyway... Or they'd just make Randy, Paula, and Simon look bad.

[ms_suzyq_2u]

I liked it when Gene Simmons was a guest Judge! That was TOO funny! I couldn't get that image of him with his tongue hanging out out of my mind!