Tribal Council (Survivor)

[AbsentElement]

In the final tribal council, out of the following pairings, who do you think would win, and why?

1) Terry vs. Aras

2) Terry vs. Cirie

3) Terry vs. Danielle

4) Aras vs. Cirie

5) Aras vs. Danielle

6) Cirie vs. Danielle

[ilovechris]

Good Question! And hard one!

1) Aras would take Terry any day because he would get all of the Casaya votes.

2) Cirie would beat Terry for the same reason as #1. I just hope Shane can get over that fact that she betrayed him. I mean someone from Casaya had to go right?

3) Terry might actually take this one because Danielle only has Aras and Cirie on her side. I think Shane and Courtney hate her and sally, austin, and bruce would most likely vote for Terry.

4) This is the toughest one...Aras might get it because he physically did better, but Cirie has played the game with extreme intelligence and has manipulated the best!

5) and 6) Danielle will never win this. (See #3)

[AbsentElement]

Well, I suppose I should have probably put my thoughts in on this one too, since I actually asked the question. :)

1) Terry vs. Aras - I have to say Terry would win this one. Terry will get Austin and Sally's votes. He will most likely also get Bruce's votes. He only needs one more to win. When you start dealing with the other Casaya members, it gets a little trickier. Courtney and Shane were both absolutely blind-sided. I don't think they know just yet exactly how they were blindsided, especially Shane. Rememer, Terry didn't vote for either one of them. Now remember, Cirie and Danielle will also be in the jury in this situation. I think Cirie would vote for Terry because of the overwhelming odds he's overcome. Danielle would likely vote for Terry as well, because she's already screwed him over. I think all of the finalist, except for Aras, have the utmost respect for Terry. He's overcome the odds, he hasn't lied to any of the jurors, and he hasn't voted for any of the jurors. I think Casaya's tribal lines will be finally broken at the last tribal council and Terry would win, probably unanimously.

2) Terry vs. Cirie - This is a little tougher, because both of them have overcome tremendous odds to get this far. Again, Sally and Austin will certainly vote for Terry. Bruce is a little more questionable. But Cirie was the mastermind behind the demise of Courtney and Shane. If they find out about that, Terry has the four votes he needs to win.

3) Terry vs. Danielle I agree. Danielle will not win this thing. Sally, Austin, Courtney and Shane vote for Terry in this situation. That's all he needs in order to win. He might get the extra vote from Bruce. But Bruce has surprised in the past and not sided with Terry. It doesn't matter anyways. Terry wins this matchup too.

4) Aras vs. Cirie - I don't know that this is so tough of a matchup to figure out. Sally and Austin will vote for Cirie. Bruce will likely vote for Cirie. Shane and Courtney will vote for Aras. Terry would vote for Cirie, and Danielle would likely vote for Cirie. I say 5 votes to 2, in favor of Cirie.

5) Aras vs. Danielle - To me, this is the toughest to figure out. Danielle's best chances are against Aras. I don't think Sally and Austin would ever vote for Aras, unless Terry convinces them that they actually should. So, for now, I'm assuming Dani gets there votes. Courtney and Shane will not vote for Dani, so Aras gets their votes. That leaves Cirie, Bruce and Terry. Terry's arch nemesis is Aras, BUT, Aras hasn't screwed him over like Dani has. So I think in this case, Terry might actually vote for Aras. With Cirie, it's just hard to tell. I really think it depends on how the next challenge and tribal council go. With Bruce, it's also hard to tell, but I think he'd side with Dani. I'd say, in this situation we could see a 4-3 vote either way, or as much as a 6-1 vote. I don't think either one would win unanimously.

6) Cirie vs. Danielle - Again, this is tough, because Cirie was the mastermind behind the demise of Courtney and Shane, BUT Danielle was in on it. Sally, Austin, and Terry vote for Cirie. With the Casaya members, it's hard to say who they would side with. For Aras' vote, it depends on what happens in the next episode. For the others already on the jury, they have been betrayed by both of them. So it may come down to final arguments. It's tough to actually pick who will win, but if it's Cirie, it will be a landslide. To win, Danielle would have to secure 100% of the Casaya jury votes.

[aztecgoods]

Also, I'm not sure how much tribal loyalty will play in that several (Cirie, Dan) p@#$ed the others off, and some may vote for Terry being that there is NO doubt he deserves to win, and is probably the best player to ever play survivor. I am thinking in the end some will take into consideration the fact that he is such a great player, possibly the greatest ever. I certainly would vote for who I believed deserved to win over alliances that didn't even get me to the final 4. Dan should probably be least likely to win being she is the spoiled, daddy's girl (or atleast perceived this way) Cirie has a good shot, Aras I would say 3rd from bottom, but it is hard to predict these things. I still think the most likely scenario is Terry taking Dan to the final 2, Terry wins. That's where I'm placing my bets.

[AbsentElement]

Also, I'm not sure how much tribal loyalty will play in that several (Cirie, Dan) p@#$ed the others off, and some may vote for Terry being that there is NO doubt he deserves to win, and is probably the best player to ever play survivor. I am thinking in the end some will take into consideration the fact that he is such a great player, possibly the greatest ever. I certainly would vote for who I believed deserved to win over alliances that didn't even get me to the final 4. Dan should probably be least likely to win being she is the spoiled, daddy's girl (or atleast perceived this way) Cirie has a good shot, Aras I would say 3rd from bottom, but it is hard to predict these things. I still think the most likely scenario is Terry taking Dan to the final 2, Terry wins. That's where I'm placing my bets.
ALL IN! Terry wins both final immunity challenges, takes Dani to the final two, and wins by a 6-1 vote (the 1 being Aras), becoming the greatest player ever in the history of Survivor. Sets two Survivor precedents in the process... 1) wins all individual immunity challenges, AND 2) first to win the car AND the million. Any bookies out there want to take me up on this? hehe. :)

[ilovechris]

Also, I'm not sure how much tribal loyalty will play in that several (Cirie, Dan) p@#$ed the others off, and some may vote for Terry being that there is NO doubt he deserves to win, and is probably the best player to ever play survivor. I am thinking in the end some will take into consideration the fact that he is such a great player, possibly the greatest ever. I certainly would vote for who I believed deserved to win over alliances that didn't even get me to the final 4. Dan should probably be least likely to win being she is the spoiled, daddy's girl (or atleast perceived this way) Cirie has a good shot, Aras I would say 3rd from bottom, but it is hard to predict these things. I still think the most likely scenario is Terry taking Dan to the final 2, Terry wins. That's where I'm placing my bets.

I agree that Terry is a stud and the best survivor player ever, but is it always the best player that wins??? And isn't it true that the person that has won the car has never won survivor. I keep watching to see if Terry will pull it off.

[AbsentElement]

I agree that Terry is a stud and the best survivor player ever, but is it always the best player that wins??? And isn't it true that the person that has won the car has never won survivor. I keep watching to see if Terry will pull it off.
I only see one scenario where he won't pull it off. That's if he loses the final immunity challenge and the others are smart enough to vote him out. They can't rely on tribal lines for votes. Really, Terry's future all boils down to that ONE immunity challenge.

I don't know if you've noticed this, but I haven't seen any mention at all, in camp, or in tribal councils or anywhere else about Terry having won the car. No mention whatsoever. Remember, there were only two people that went with him and knew about it. Did they tell the others? hmmm...