Who goes next?

[carlwilson2]

I see Aaron leaving next followed by Tim. Then Mike will go followed by Casey. That will leave Crystal, Lee and Siobhan in the final three. And everyone knows that anything can happen from there.

[Teddy G]

Aaron should've left last week, so I'll pick him to go this week.

[Chopper7]

Aaron can't do any worse than he did last week. I predict at least two more weeks. This week Siobhan goes, then Mike, then Tim, then Aaron. And the judges can suck on their stupid save. Out of the remaining three, who knows.

[Teddy G]

I would rather have Big Mike leave because he looks like ten tons of annoying in a two-ton sack, but I'm sure he'll last longer than at least one of the girls, because the show is cool like that.

[Chopper7]

I don't know why everyone thinks Aaron is finally leaving us next week. His success has nothing to do with his voice, performances, or charisma. The first is thin and reedy, the second have been uniformly awful, and he has zero appeal to normal human beings. The problem is that normal human beings don't vote. The voters are pre-human text/cell addicted little girls who love weak non-threatening little boys. Aaron fills the bill and will last three more weeks.

[Teddy G]

The problem is that normal human beings don't vote. The voters are pre-human text/cell addicted little girls who love weak non-threatening little boys. Aaron fills the bill and will last three more weeks.

I want to know who the hell is voting for Mike.

[IdolMe]

Mike or Aaron, but unfortunately people probably aren't voting for mike due to the fact that he was saved. Looks like people value the Judges decisions unfortunately.

[Lancelot of Camelot]

Mike should sing Wonderful World. That will carry him through at least another week. Aaron has the country music vote is probably more important than teenage chick vote which probably goes more to Casey, Tim, and Lee than him. The people voting for Mike are probably black to a high percentage and the others voting for him are people that appreciate he has one of the best voices this season.

[Chopper7]

Whatever Mike does, (and I doubt he would be dumb enough to do "wonderful world"), he will dork it up to suit the lowest common denominator voter, in other words most of them. Note that singing a brazen "Eleanor Rigby" almost put him out, so expect nothing special from him anymore. BTW, I wish Lilly were still on the show. I just discovered this picture she posted on her MySpace.

[Chopper7]

After last night's "inspiring", I now think Casey is vulnerable especially after the judges threw him on the coals and then stupidly praised that mumbling nonsense from Lee. If not Casey, maybe Siobhan, but her fan base is pretty strong, so maybe she hangs around a couple of weeks. I doubt Aaron bites it, too many tweenies twittering away out there. Geez, who cares, most of them should have been gone weeks ago. BTW, there are two rating outfits in addition to DialIdol I look at: Idol Chatter and votefair.org. Both have onsite voting, and participants can vote only once. Interesting. They both have Siobhan pretty safe, but Chatter voters weren't "inspired" by her.

[Lancelot of Camelot]

After last night's "inspiring", I now think Casey is vulnerable especially after the judges threw him on the coals and then stupidly praised that mumbling nonsense from Lee. If not Casey, maybe Siobhan, but her fan base is pretty strong, so maybe she hangs around a couple of weeks. I doubt Aaron bites it, too many tweenies twittering away out there. Geez, who cares, most of them should have been gone weeks ago. BTW, there are two rating outfits in addition to DialIdol I look at: Idol Chatter and votefair.org. Both have onsite voting, and participants can vote only once. Interesting. They both have Siobhan pretty safe, but Chatter voters weren't "inspired" by her.

Good to hear that Siobhan is safe. I figured she was. I am starting to think she has a chance to outlast all of the guys. One problem with the sites that have online voting is that they are likely not representative of the actual voters. Dial Idol just samples busy signals and that is representative of actual voters. That is why I prefer Dial Idol for predictive ability.

[Lapin]

Is it just me , the noble Lapin , or does anyone else out there think that Crystal is a tad overrated ?

Bartend , another Sam's please !

A bientot !

[Lancelot of Camelot]

Is it just me , the noble Lapin , or does anyone else out there think that Crystal is a tad overrated ?

Bartend , another Sam's please !

A bientot !

She is a tad overrated but she is quite talented.

[Chopper7]

As you said, none of these sites is that reliable. I still think all the negative crap from the judges could send Siobhan home, if not this week, probably next week.

Good to hear that Siobhan is safe. I figured she was. I am starting to think she has a chance to outlast all of the guys. One problem with the sites that have online voting is that they are likely not representative of the actual voters. Dial Idol just samples busy signals and that is representative of actual voters. That is why I prefer Dial Idol for predictive ability.

[Teddy G]

Is it just me , the noble Lapin , or does anyone else out there think that Crystal is a tad overrated ?

Bartend , another Sam's please !

A bientot !

Yeah, if you're not into soulful, bluesy type rock, and more into that sissy pop theatrical stuff, you probably won't like her.

[Lancelot of Camelot]

Yeah, if you're not into soulful, bluesy type rock, and more into that sissy pop theatrical stuff, you probably won't like her.

Who said anything about not liking her. All he said was a TAD overrated. A TAD is not much. I agree that she is a TAD overrated.

[Chopper7]

What the heck. The Internet is for arguing, so.... What does it mean to say she's overrated, and how much is a tad? That remark sounds like something Kara would say. You know, it's in English, but it doesn't mean anything. To whom are you comparing her unfavorably (even if just a tad!)?

Who said anything about not liking her. All he said was a TAD overrated. A TAD is not much. I agree that she is a TAD overrated.

[Lancelot of Camelot]

What the heck. The Internet is for arguing, so.... What does it mean to say she's overrated, and how much is a tad? That remark sounds like something Kara would say. You know, it's in English, but it doesn't mean anything. To whom are you comparing her unfavorably (even if just a tad!)?

Saying she is a tad overrated is not comparing her to anyone. It is comparing her to the hype she is getting. She is very good and probably the best of this years contestants. However, when she did that weak performance during Elvis week and the judges and many here are all acting like it was the greatest performance ever that is what I base my tad overrated agreement on.

[Lancelot of Camelot]

As you said, none of these sites is that reliable. I still think all the negative crap from the judges could send Siobhan home, if not this week, probably next week.
I don't think the voting public gives a rat's ass about what the judges are saying about Siobhan. The people who like Siobhan are particular and not likely to be swayed by the judges constant comments against her.

[Lancelot of Camelot]

OK My official prediction for who gets booted tonight. Tim. I don't buy the possibility of Casey going home. Mike would be my second most likely to get the boot and then Casey.

[Teddy G]

Saying she is a tad overrated is not comparing her to anyone. It is comparing her to the hype she is getting. She is very good and probably the best of this years contestants. However, when she did that weak performance during Elvis week and the judges and many here are all acting like it was the greatest performance ever that is what I base my tad overrated agreement on.

Whatever, Lanceroo.


If she was some effeminate dude who sang nothing but pop or glam rock, or some big black dude, who sings like a sissy, you'd think she was the greatest thing since sliced bread.

But, since you're not into her style of music, you say she overrated.

Okay.

[halman99]

based on last night's performances, casey should go home, but michael wasn't much better. tim and siobhan both did better than the judges gave them credit for, so i think they both survive. it could be aaron, but then i thought that before.... whatever happens, i think lee is very safe and crystal.... no i don't think she's even a "tad" overrated!

[Lancelot of Camelot]

Whatever, Lanceroo.


If she was some effeminate dude who sang nothing but pop or glam rock, or some big black dude, who sings like a sissy, you'd think she was the greatest thing since sliced bread.

But, since you're not into her style of music, you say she overrated.

Okay.

Teddy??? R U Serious. I am the original lover of Crystals style of music. I was liking her before you knew she existed. Ask Chopper if you need to. I think he was her first supporter and I was next.

[Chopper7]

Who gives a crap? Let's argue about something real!

Teddy??? R U Serious. I am the original lover of Crystals style of music. I was liking her before you knew she existed. Ask Chopper if you need to. I think he was her first supporter and I was next.

[Teddy G]

Teddy??? R U Serious. I am the original lover of Crystals style of music.


Was that before, or after you started listening to Justin Bieber, and making threads in honor of him? LOL


I was liking her before you knew she existed. Ask Chopper if you need to. I think he was her first supporter and I was next.

Oh Yeah, what happened?

Did you decide she wasn't your cup of tea because she probably has more testosterone, than most of the artists you listen to?

[Lancelot of Camelot]

Was that before, or after you started listening to Justin Bieber, and making threads in honor of him? LOL




Oh Yeah, what happened?

Did you decide she wasn't your cup of tea because she probably has more testosterone, than most of the artists you listen to?

Threads in honor of Justin Bieber LMAO. I agreed that Crystal might be a tad overrated. Oh well you win this argument. I can't stand Crystal. I actually never could. I just posted all those things about how great she was to throw people off. Tim was actually the one I wanted to win all along and now I won't watch anymore.

[Teddy G]

Threads in honor of Justin Bieber LMAO. I agreed that Crystal might be a tad overrated. Oh well you win this argument. I can't stand Crystal. I actually never could. I just posted all those things about how great she was to throw people off. Tim was actually the one I wanted to win all along and now I won't watch anymore.

Well, maybe they'll have an Adam Lambert 2.0 for you to root for next year.

[Chopper7]

I would have loved to see Tim win, thereby proving once and for all what a fraud this show is. I was beginning to think it might happen, but there are too many pretty, sissy, and manly boys to go around; tweenies can't vote for all of them. Hey Lance, don't use sarcasm; you're not up to it.

Threads in honor of Justin Bieber LMAO. I agreed that Crystal might be a tad overrated. Oh well you win this argument. I can't stand Crystal. I actually never could. I just posted all those things about how great she was to throw people off. Tim was actually the one I wanted to win all along and now I won't watch anymore.

[Lancelot of Camelot]

I would have loved to see Tim win, thereby proving once and for all what a fraud this show is. I was beginning to think it might happen, but there are too many pretty, sissy, and manly boys to go around; tweenies can't vote for all of them. Hey Lance, don't use sarcasm; you're not up to it.

Chopper now I am not allowed to use sarcasm? What other rules are in place?:eek:

[IdolMe]

Chopper now I am not allowed to use sarcasm? What other rules are in place?:eek:

Were you using sarcasm? I thought you were serious. LOL :confused:

[Chopper7]

Nah, go ahead and be sarcastic till the cows come home, but you suck at it. I'm lousy at lots of stuff, but that doesn't stop me.

Chopper now I am not allowed to use sarcasm? What other rules are in place?:eek: