Anoop Desai

[ricocharlie]

I can't believe america sent him home, he is so talented! I was so mad watching American Idol last night, i think Matt or Danny should have gone. Plus, Danny is so boring, very forgettable...

[laraine]

Well I agree that Anoop is very talented, but I have to disagree that Danny should have gone home, he will very likely be in the final.... I think Anoop will get a deal anyway, he has a lovely rich tone to his voice.

[Eileenacanadian]

While Danny isn't my favorite I can't say he should have been sent home. He is a good singer. A little predictable but he has a nice voice. Needs to liven up his song choices but again he has a good voice.

[Eileenacanadian]

After seeing Matt's performance I was disappointed the "save" was WASTED on him! I guess i'm still a little sour grapish on that :)

[Teddy G]

I can't believe america sent him home, he is so talented! I was so mad watching American Idol last night, i think Matt or Danny should have gone. Plus, Danny is so boring, very forgettable...

And Anoop isn't boring?

Please, his ballads just bore the hell out of me.

[laraine]

No, I don't find Anoop boring in the slightest. I would sooner watch a nice understated heartfelt vocal from him, than the over the top theatrical acrobats of another contestant.

[ricocharlie]

No, I don't find Anoop boring in the slightest. I would sooner watch a nice understated heartfelt vocal from him, than the over the top theatrical acrobats of another contestant.



I know, Anoop is so not boring! I loved his performances.
I think Adam is good but he is over the top sometimes.

[ricocharlie]

And Anoop isn't boring?

Please, his ballads just bore the hell out of me.


Then, who do you like on American Idol???????

[ricocharlie]

Well I agree that Anoop is very talented, but I have to disagree that Danny should have gone home, he will very likely be in the final.... I think Anoop will get a deal anyway, he has a lovely rich tone to his voice.


What do you think about Matt? I would have rather seen him go home too.

[Eileenacanadian]

Matt sucked, he should have gone home before anoop or LiL.

[laraine]

I wasn't upset to see Lil go, as week after week, she picked the wrong song, you can only get away with that for so long. Matt on the other hand, has been very good previously, but last night, omg, that was not good. They must have a pretty restrictive song list to choose from, thats all I can say, disco week with no Chic, Sister Sledge, Oddysey, Gap Band, Kool & The Gang... what goes on???:confused:

[Teddy G]

They must have a pretty restrictive song list to choose from, thats all I can say, disco week with no Chic, Sister Sledge, Oddysey, Gap Band, Kool & The Gang... what goes on???:confused:

It didn't really seem like Disco week to me. There were only a couple that actually sounded like Disco.

The problem is, if they sounded too much like Disco, then Simon would've than Simon would've whined that they sounded too old fashioned, or karaoke.

He always encourages them to sound totally different, than what the theme actually is.

[laraine]

I'd have thought that at least 3 of the remaining acts could have made a disco song sound current, with a new arrangement, without turning it into a ballad. The whole point of disco is its upbeat...:confused: