Wed. 4-25 Show ???

[IdolMe2]

How did they all do? Just wondering on the West Coast!:argue:

[Magicmarkerman]

Kellie sucked and got an extrememly harsh review! It's about time... Elliott kicked butt completely with rave reviews from ALL judges, so much so that Paula was so moved she was crying, and Simon called him 'Superb'!!!

[Kristi_M]

Elliot is awesome!!! My new favorite! He gets my votes tonite!! GO ELLIOT!!

[Kristi_M]

Elliot should win this thing!

[Magicmarkerman]

Elliot should win this thing!

I'm glad people are starting to recognize and appreciate his talent... He is probaly the most talented out of the whole group, and is the most consitant...You can tell he loves what he does, just like Taylor... The guys have it this year...

[Watcher]

Elliott has always been fairly good but it's still too early to tell at this stage.
I think he needs some strong encouragement.

[tnell]

Elliott will not win this thing. He has a great voice, but his look will keep hime out of the final.

[bertha]

I think that tonight Ms. McPhee and Paris got their big heads deflated, effective around 8 central time. I have been feuding with people since the season started that Elliot had the best voice, and plus he just seems like such a humble, beautiful person. Anyone who doesn't vote for him is extremely shallow. For cryin out loud, teeth can be fixed!

[Watcher]

Don't be too hard on the girls, Bertha. They are all trying very hard. I don't want to be in their positions at all (not that I can!).

[cloie4me]

I think that tonight Ms. McPhee and Paris got their big heads deflated, effective around 8 central time. I have been feuding with people since the season started that Elliot had the best voice, and plus he just seems like such a humble, beautiful person. Anyone who doesn't vote for him is extremely shallow. For cryin out loud, teeth can be fixed!


:heartpump Cloie's got a new friend!

[Helen]

I tried to get votes for Elliot after Ryan said, why is he in the bottem 3, Elliot is becoming more sure of him self and that is the ingredient for him to win this thing, keep going strong and believe in yourself, Elliot. You are a humble person and know what you want, go for it!!

[LoveElliott802]

Elliott will not win this thing. He has a great voice, but his look will keep hime out of the final.


You haven't forgotten about 300 pound Ruben Studdard have you?

[SouthernRockGirl]

Elliot is by far the most talented person on this show. Here is the thing guys - You cannot teach Pigs to sing - and this boy can sing. They can teach him how to be charismatic and act on stage. Have you seen Carrie Underwood - she had no personality on stage - but she can SING!!! Elliot would be in this for the long haul with a career because he so FLIPPING Talented! Taylor is the suck and does nothing for me whatsoever. I think Chris did alright last night - but the most consistent person all season is ELLIOTT!!!!!

Go Yamin!

[FalseIdol]

They can teach him how to be charismatic and act on stage.

Wrong, wrong, wrong. You can make someone a more technically proficient singer through hard work, training and selection of the right material. But you cannot suddenly inject a person in their late 20's with a personality.

Elliott can sing but he has all the personality of rock; which is why he has no chance of winning this contest.

[Tommy J]

Elliot had the best male performance and Paris had the best female performance. Taylor and Katharine had the worst.

[Kristi_M]

People criticizing Elliot for his looks?? I though he looked darn good last night! He has kind of a sophisticated look that I find appealing. Teeth, so what? I didn't even notice! And the guy has major talent, and WOW, can he sing!

[McFeverish.....]

I admit that Elliot is starting to grow on me...but it may be too late.

If he wins (unlikely) then I'd be okay with it. He is a good singer at least.

My favorites last night though was Kat...then Chris....then Elliot..